Concealed carry~what should he pick?

.22LRGUY

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
178   0   1
Location
Ontario
OK...sort of "click bait" on the thread title, but the question is a real one. As much as I'm a fan of handguns, there are no ranges close to me that I can afford where I could use one..so..they're not really "on my radar" at all. I watch from a distance, shoot pistols when the opportunity presents itself, but I'm certainly no authority on the subject. That aside..

My brother lives/works in the southern US in a state where he can apply for concealed carry. Other than handling (not firing) some handguns in a few shops down there, he has no experience shooting them. However, he has himself convinced that he needs one, and is looking into training courses to make sure he'll be able to use the thing safely. I personally think the whole idea is a bad one, but I'm taking him at his word that he has every intention of getting trained to use it, and range time/practice are both HUGE parts of the equation. He is a very smart guy, and makes a very good living down there. He never cuts corners on anything. The "why?"~he tells me he's concerned for his safety at times, and that of his family. He tells me he's interested in possibly two guns, something like a Sig P226 and something smaller..sort of a "pocket pistol". The Sig was recommended by a guy he knows down there, and by at least one of the area shops he visited.

Now, before anyone comments on the good/bad idea aspect of all of this~I've already sort of drilled him on the importance of really knowing a gun before you can trust yourself with it, and, told him it's a TERRIBLE idea to get a handgun(s) in the absence of proper training. I don't think I can say much more than that, but also know that his thinking is very much an "American" one when it comes to guns at this point. I urged him to get a 22 pistol and after at least a dozen or so hours of range time, THEN go shopping.

So, with all that said~I'm looking for ideas on what to suggest for him. (he asked) I know I've enjoyed shooting CZ75s most....but he's a smaller-stature guy than I am with smaller hands. In other words, I don't think something like a 1911 would be a great choice! Leaving anything custom out of the equation, knowing his lack of experience but willingness to get trained... what makes/models should he be looking at if 9mm is his choice? Budget is not a concern, but ease of use...easy to control....are. One feature he saw that intrigued him was pistol grips with the laser built-in. I've seen those, just not sure if they're any good...more gimmicky than not, etc.

Thanks for taking a moment to reply.
 
My personal favorite for CCW, Glock 19: light, 15 rounds magazines, lots of holsters options



if he's a ''smaller guy with small hands'', a P226 might be a bit too big too CCW.

Sig just reintroduced the P225, very slim pistol and easily concealable. Downside: 8 rounds of 9mm in the magazine. P228 is a downsized P226.
 
Glock, 19 or 26 for 9mm, 23 or 27 for .40S&W

19/23 are compact, 26/27 are subcompact. All have 22 kits available for handling practice and cheap range time.

Others will weigh in, these would be my choices. For CCW I wouldn't put the gimmicky crap on it. Get a quality holster as well. If new to firearms then training will be an asset for sure.
 
Agree. A good stainless S&W model 60 in .38 Special would serve quite well.

Bad idea. Great to carry, not so great to shoot, either in practice or for real. I've talked to more than a few guys and girls who have been in "for real, putting metal in to meat" gunfights, and not one of them ever said "I wish I had a smaller gun that held less rounds". Just getting marginally competent with a J requires some serious effort, let alone maintaining those skills - a G19 is exponentially easier to shoot well, less abusive and there is good market support for it (holsters, mags, ammo, sights, etc).

Now if you're the reincarnation of Jelly Bryce and can knock plates at 25m all day long under time and never miss?? Carry on...
 
Unless there's some particular reason why he doesn't want to start with the most obvious choice, the answer is a Glock 19.
 
Agree. A good stainless S&W model 60 in .38 Special would serve quite well.

That sounds like something that someone who doesn't actually shoot them would say. I've owned and shot a lot of revolvers - and I'm a big fan of the J frame, and the model 38 (Airweight Bodyguard) in particular - but my model 60 (Stainless Chief's Special) was one of the worst revolvers I've ever used. Relatively heavy, sharp-edged, and (because of the high bore axis) with relatively heavy recoil, it was a bear to shoot, and it would regularly cut you. No thank you... I sold it. I've sold a bunch of guns in my time, and I still miss most of them, but I can honestly say that I have never, ever, missed that Model 60. And...lets be honest...for a whole host of reasons, revolvers are obsolete.

If the person wants something to actually carry and to actually shoot, he probably wants a Glock 19.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom