I couldn't remember what the Lott recoil was and I needed the info for myself, plus there's numbers for some calibers that I have, just for comparison. The numbers reflect the actual reloading data and rifle weights of my guns.
The .375H&H info is from
www.ReloadersNewst.com. There are no loads published for the .375Ruger.
I use the Recoil Calculator at
www.RealGuns.com.
The numbers don't lie; the recoil from a .30-06 to a .375H&H (and the Ruger would be pretty much identical) is double.
Even though the .45-70 has a lower number, then say the .375H&H, the recoil characteristics of the short Marlin M-1895 Guide Gun, create a "felt recoil" that is a lot worse, at least off the bench.
I will add that the Marlin M-1895XLR .45-70 is a way nicer rifle to shoot because of the longer barrel; 24" vs 18.5. I own one of each...
Also note that it is virtually the same as the .338WM, but when you compare the stock designs and recoil characteristics of the Marlin lever action versus any good bolt action, the .338WM is much nicer to shoot.
Some Recoil Numbers to Compare
Recoil: .30-06
Bullet Weight - grains -------- 165
Muzzle Velocity - ft./sec. ---- 2850
Powder Weight - grains ------58grs IMR-4350
Gun Weight - lbs. -----------7.5
Recoil = 23 ft.-lbs.
-----------------------------------------------------
Recoil: .338WM
Bullet Weight - grains -------- 225
Muzzle Velocity - ft./sec. ---- 2800
Powder Weight - grains ------67grs IMR-4350
Gun Weight - lbs. -----------7.5
Recoil = 38 ft.-lbs.
------------------------------------------------------
Recoil: .375H&H From
www.ReloadersNest.com
Bullet Weight - grains -------- 300
Muzzle Velocity - ft./sec. ---- 2615
Powder Weight - grains ------73grs RL-15
Gun Weight - lbs. -----------8.5 (I assume that rifle weight)
Recoil = 47 ft.-lbs.
------------------------------------------------------
Recoil: .45-70Gov't
Bullet Weight - grains -------- 400
Muzzle Velocity - ft./sec. ---- 1695
Powder Weight - grains ------52.5grs H4895
Gun Weight - lbs. -----------7.5
Recoil = 36 ft.-lbs.
------------------------------------------------------
Recoil: .458 Lott
Bullet Weight - grains -------- 500
Muzzle Velocity - ft./sec. ---- 2235
Powder Weight - grains ------75.5grs H335
Gun Weight - lbs. -----------9.5
Recoil = 72 ft.-lbs.
------------------------------------------------------
It is my opinion that anybody that lives in and hunts in grizzly country would be well served with any of these cartridges: .35Whelen, .338WM, .375H&H(Ruger).
I have checked out the .375Rugers at various online sales outlets. I think it is a helluva bargain.
And I repeat this every time I think about it;
the .375Ruger is going to make a lot of excellent vintage H&H's available over the next decade or so. And I think that is a very good thing!
