- Location
- Fraser Valley
See I got this kid. 
He does not want me to buy him a Glock. He wants a revolver.
What do I get? He's 14.
VV
He does not want me to buy him a Glock. He wants a revolver.What do I get? He's 14.
VV
Have to get a revolver
- Thread starter Village Vixen
- Start date
kokanee king
Regular
- Location
- Didsbury, Alberta
Get him a .357. That way he can shoot both the .357 as well as the .38
kokanee king
Regular
- Location
- Didsbury, Alberta
Am I? Im only going on info that i was told from an old timer at my range who shoots both calibers in his .357
Davy Crockett
CGN Ultra frequent flyer
- Location
- Fraser Valley
No, that info is correct. I'm not sure what Mike's getting at, maybe the kid is wrong to want a revolver?
I'd suggest a .22 unless ammo cost is not an issue. I can't offer any specific suggestions as I'm not a revolver guy but I'm sure others will.
notsorichguy
CGN Ultra frequent flyer
- Location
- The city that rhymes with fun
Start him on a single 6 or some other variant. I have a heritage .22/.22 mag from Kodiak outpost. The fit and finish is almost exactly the same as a single six, only 1/3rd the cost. If he likes that, then get him a .357/.38.....
My opinion..... its worth the paper it written on! lol!
My opinion..... its worth the paper it written on!
lol!
Sounds like this kid has a good solid head on his shoulders....
Vixen, if you and your kid would like to try out a S&W Model 19 and a Model 28, both in .357 magnum, then PM me and we can meet at my range. Or just wander over to DVC Ventures just off the Maryhill bypass. They've got a display case full of revolvers that you and your son(?) can shoot.
I was all about the semis at first and then in a weak moment I thought I'd try a Model 19 for giggles. By half way through the second cylinder of 6 shots I was sold on the revolver as a really fun way too shoot handguns. There's still lots of room in this world for semis but there will always be a soft spot in my heart for the good ol' revolver. They are a bit more deliberate, a bit slower and can be a bit more involved in deciding if you shoot single action or double action. And they are a whole lot more easy to do nice tight groupings with less concentration than with most semis.
Vixen, if you and your kid would like to try out a S&W Model 19 and a Model 28, both in .357 magnum, then PM me and we can meet at my range. Or just wander over to DVC Ventures just off the Maryhill bypass. They've got a display case full of revolvers that you and your son(?) can shoot.
I was all about the semis at first and then in a weak moment I thought I'd try a Model 19 for giggles. By half way through the second cylinder of 6 shots I was sold on the revolver as a really fun way too shoot handguns. There's still lots of room in this world for semis but there will always be a soft spot in my heart for the good ol' revolver. They are a bit more deliberate, a bit slower and can be a bit more involved in deciding if you shoot single action or double action. And they are a whole lot more easy to do nice tight groupings with less concentration than with most semis.
Best bet will be a S&W K frame in .357.serious caliber in a medium weight firearms,trigger usually are excellent and the revolver always go bang with good ammo!So, your boys wont have to think or included more procedure in his shooting than point, shoot, eject empty and reload. He can do a lot of dry firing with a S&W with no problem. Dont shoot it with too much hot .357 loads and the gun will last. Double action rev are harder too shoot in DA, but with practice, I think this is the best firearms too learn trigger control and sight alignement.
And when he will be good with the S&W, a nice semi will be is prize!!!
Yves
My 2cents...
And when he will be good with the S&W, a nice semi will be is prize!!!
Yves
My 2cents...
my vote would be either the s&w 686 or the gp100- either are good guns- the n frame smith is too heavy for what it is, and start off with the lighter 38 spcl loads- he'll learn a host of things and it's a good draw gun as well- my only regret is that we can't get the 4 inch barrel on Kanada anymore , as that was ideal- smith model 19 in 4 inch was just about perfect, unless you wanted to do a LOT of 357- that as the reason for the l series
and for god's sake GET A STAINLESS- it's worth the extra bucks in claening-
i started of with a colt 45 m1911, but finally transitioned to a revolver a couple of years back- my goto is still the 1911, but that's more training than everything else-however, for recreational use( which is the real sceneario in canada) i've got a ruger redhawk in both 7.5 and 5 inch- the 7.5 wears a scope, but would suspect the redhawk in 44 is too much gun to start with- don't want to spook him right out of the gate
and for god's sake GET A STAINLESS- it's worth the extra bucks in claening-
i started of with a colt 45 m1911, but finally transitioned to a revolver a couple of years back- my goto is still the 1911, but that's more training than everything else-however, for recreational use( which is the real sceneario in canada) i've got a ruger redhawk in both 7.5 and 5 inch- the 7.5 wears a scope, but would suspect the redhawk in 44 is too much gun to start with- don't want to spook him right out of the gate
Last edited:
MauserMike
CGN Ultra frequent flyer
- Location
- SW Ontario
Vixen,
x2 - very cool to have matched K frame revolvers in .22 & .38/.357. The ##### with a lot of S&W revolvers is they are 12(6). Its mostly the K frames you see with the 6" barrels.
686 is nice too but balances differently than the older ones. I find them a little more muzzle heavy with the full length underlug.
Get a S&W. Colts don't have very good long term durability and few gunsmiths work on them. Rugers are strong, but have lousy triggers.
An N frame S&W with a tapered barrel (Model 27 or 28) actually weighs about the same as an L frame (586/686) with the lugged barrel. The choice between the two boils down to individual preference in terms of balance and looks.
The K frame .357s should also be fine, unless you plan on shooting a lot of full-power .357. If you don't need .357, a Model 14 in .38 Special is another option.
If a .22 is an option on the table, get a Model 17.
An N frame S&W with a tapered barrel (Model 27 or 28) actually weighs about the same as an L frame (586/686) with the lugged barrel. The choice between the two boils down to individual preference in terms of balance and looks.
The K frame .357s should also be fine, unless you plan on shooting a lot of full-power .357. If you don't need .357, a Model 14 in .38 Special is another option.
If a .22 is an option on the table, get a Model 17.
I've gotta agree that a S&W K22 would be a great start. There's been a couple in the EE lately (17-2, 17-3). They're not as inexpensive as some others but a great sa/da revolver. And it's cheap to shoot .22lr.
If he likes that, upgrade to a similiar revolver in .38/357. S&W model 28's are always nice.
Hmmm....seems like I'm like a little S&W biased. Oh well...
If he likes that, upgrade to a similiar revolver in .38/357. S&W model 28's are always nice.
Hmmm....seems like I'm like a little S&W biased. Oh well...
Last edited:
- Location
- Fraser Valley
LOL yeah I figure thats what he meant. Slavex thought it was weird too. Its ok. This momma thinks her kid is cool. Some would argue that we are both a bit "off"
Sounds like this kid has a good solid head on his shoulders....
Vixen, if you and your kid would like to try out a S&W Model 19 and a Model 28, both in .357 magnum, then PM me and we can meet at my range. Or just wander over to DVC Ventures just off the Maryhill bypass. They've got a display case full of revolvers that you and your son(?) can shoot.
I was all about the semis at first and then in a weak moment I thought I'd try a Model 19 for giggles. By half way through the second cylinder of 6 shots I was sold on the revolver as a really fun way too shoot handguns. There's still lots of room in this world for semis but there will always be a soft spot in my heart for the good ol' revolver. They are a bit more deliberate, a bit slower and can be a bit more involved in deciding if you shoot single action or double action. And they are a whole lot more easy to do nice tight groupings with less concentration than with most semis.
I will take you up on your kind offer.
Thank you!!! everyone for all your advice. I have printed the thread off and will take it when I go shopping with the kid. I will let you know when I get the thing for him too.
VV
S&W model 17, .22LR.
It has a great DA/SA trigger, is very accurate, shoots all .22 rimfire ammo including CB's. A VG to EX 17 will cost you $350 - 400 and it will appreciate in value so if you sell it in the future you will at least get your money back.
It has a great DA/SA trigger, is very accurate, shoots all .22 rimfire ammo including CB's. A VG to EX 17 will cost you $350 - 400 and it will appreciate in value so if you sell it in the future you will at least get your money back.
- Location
- Somewhere on the Hudson Bay Coast
A K frame or an L frame Smith .357 is probably the correct answer. If you can find one with a 5" barrel so much the better. If he's a big kid, a N frame gun is a good choice but these are heavier than one needs for a .357, and they require big hands for a proper grip. If I was going to get an N frame gun it would be a .44 or a .45. While some might raise an eye brow at these rounds being suggested for a beginner, a handloader can load mild ammo as he can with the .357 or a .38.
I actually like the K frame M-10 .38 Special with the tapered barrel. This is a fixed sight gun, but I like the lines, and there seem to be quite a few used examples available right now that are inexpensive.
I actually like the K frame M-10 .38 Special with the tapered barrel. This is a fixed sight gun, but I like the lines, and there seem to be quite a few used examples available right now that are inexpensive.
