Beginner Handgun

Asking for advice on the net for best Beginner handgun is akin to asking for best first bf/gf; you're never get the correct answer.

Best is try a variety of brand/caliber by renting at a range or find a handgun buddy. Or buy something popular that is easy to sell/trade on EE.

Each of us can tell you our favorite favor of ice cream; you'll only know yours when you tried them all.
 
Somethings are better learned from dry firing than from live fire, so if you do choose a rimfire, get a good one, get some snap caps so you don't damage the edges of the chambers, and begin your practice at home. Remember that when the hammer falls, the bullet will hit what the front sight covers if it were live fire, and you will clearly see what the sight covers when the hammer falls when your sight picture is not disturbed by the violence of live fire; even with a rimfire. Practice loading and unloading the gun, you'll have to load and unload far more often then you'll shoot it. If you choose a centerfire gun, you don't need snap caps to dry fire, but snap caps or some easily identifiable dummy rounds are useful for loading unloading drills, or to practice clearing stoppages if you choose an auto pistol over a revolver. If you want to practice drawing the gun from a holster, snap caps or dummy rounds are useful here to. The draw should be smooth and fluid, so start slow until you get the steps down, and speed will come with practice. Again, the gun will be drawn and returned to the holster more than its fired.

Lots of guys have presented the positive aspects of choosing a rimfire pistol as a first gun, but lets for a moment consider the negatives.

The report of a Hi Speed .22 LR from a typical 4.5"-6" barrel is louder and sharper than the deeper flatter bang of a .38 squib load. Yes you can get standard velocity .22 LR ammo, but when you're at Canadian Tire and suddenly remember that you need a brick of .22s, guess what you'll get.

While everyone has pointed out the low cost of rimfire shooting, using primer propelled wax or rubber bullets in a CF revolver costs no more. You might want to dedicate some brass to this chore and drill out the flash holes so the primers don't back out. Recoil is almost nonexistent with these rounds, but they are a bit smokey. A .38 or a .44 pushed into a cake of paraffin and fired with a primer will penetrate a cardboard box at 20' so this ammo is not benign and should not be used carelessly.

The bigger that the holes are in your target, the better your shooting will look. Lets say you shoot a 4" group at 10 yards. If the holes are from a .45 the group looks quite good (although its not) and you might be tempted to carry the target around and brag a little. But shoot a 4" group with a .22, and you'll be tempted to squirrel the target away where nobody can see it.

Next there's what I call centerfire fear. This happens when a shooter who is trained on a rimfire rifle or pistol moves up to a centerfire gun. There is a sense of foreboding which he must fight his way through, although this can usually be put aside quickly with the firing of a few rounds, but it does present a real barrier for some. For that reason I would prefer to begin a new shooter on both rimfire and centerfire guns at the same time and if that's not possible then begin with a centerfire. I started my grandson on a light loaded .30/06, and he's turned into a competent and confident field shot.

The last one only applies if you shoot outdoors in the cold. Rimfire ammo doesn't shoot well in the cold, and you'll freeze your fingers attempting to load the gun. Centerfire ammo is large enough to handle with thin gloves on, and the cylinders and magazines of centerfire guns are typically easier to load.
 
Last edited:
+1 on that. Ideally you would know a shooter that will take you to their range to try their gun(s) and they may know others that will let you try their guns. There's no substitution for live fire. Second best option is to try different models in a retail outlet.

Yea, you have to consider "the cost of practice". I know some people think the .22lr pistol is wimpy, so they wouldn't consider anything less than a 9mm.

However consider the difference in ammo costs. Decent .22lr will run you about $25 to $30 after taxes for 500 rounds. 9mm about $18 after taxes for 50 rounds. So to shoot 500 rounds of 9mm is going to cost $180!!! While the guy with the .22lr could shoot 3000+ rounds for the same price.

So who is the better shot? The guy who shoots six times more than the other guy. Because practice makes perfect, as the saying goes.

Anyway, eventually you'll have the funds to buy multiple pistols of your choice. I'm just trying to illustrate that running a gun can be really expensive and if you want to learn to shoot well it has to be within your budget, etc.

Best of luck with your decision, and safety first.
 
Yea, you have to consider "the cost of practice". I know some people think the .22lr pistol is wimpy, so they wouldn't consider anything less than a 9mm.


On that note, if I HAD to recommend an actual pistol instead of just "borrow and try as many as you can through friends/ranges/shops", I'd give the nod to the Sig 226 Classic 22. Cheap(ish) pistol, cheap ammo, and then when you're ready to move to a higher caliber you can buy the exchange kit (new barrel, slide, springs, magazine) for a 9mm, .40 or .357 Sig and use it on the same frame. Doing that gives you both calibers, lets you start small if you want, and for less overall cost than just buying a Sig 226 in a centerfire caliber to begin with.
 
If I had to start again and own 1 handgun. I'm leaning towards a stainless colt 1911 in 45 acp.

Used, you could get one for 1000 dollars.

You would have to invest in a reloading set up to afford to shoot it...

However, I recommend that you get a ruger 22 and a norinco 1911.
 
To add to my earlier post I'll just add what I say to others in person if my opinion is sought out. If a .22 pistol is not your first handgun it jolly well should be your second.

There's a number of folks out there to whom blasting away with a lot of recoil is more important than becoming an accurate shooter. And there's even the very rare soul that can shoot well despite never having a .22. But for the rest of us that are merely human and still want to become better shooters the lowly .22 pistol is the better training tool.

Me? I actually LIKE rimfire pistols and revolvers. Yet my handgun collection spans from .22 to .44Mag. So I'd like to think I can safely claim that I'm not afraid of recoil. Yet, odd though it seems to some, my handgun collection is just under half .22LR guns.
 
I just wanted to chime in with my experience.... ASK yourself what kind of shooting do you want to do.?

If you want to shoot Bullseye type... get a .22 then a .45
If you want to shoot Cowboy type.... Get a cowboy gun.. or a pair of them
If you want to shoot Action shooting type.. Like IPSC or IDPA.. get the gun you want to have and shoot it.. Glock, CZ shadow, M&P does not really matter..
because shooting a .22 has little to do with Action shooting.. IMHO..
There is a whole different skill set you need to learn so get the gun and start learning..
IMHO shooting an all metal gun like a CZ shadow is easier to learn on than a Glock or an XD or M&P..
I know .. i tried the plastic gun.. thing and ended up selling it..

Good Luck and have fun..

RDG
 
So I got out and went to Target. Took a look at what's actually out there. I think I've got it down to starting with a 9mm.

So far my options at this point are Glock, Beretta 92fs, Sig p226.

Any input on these choices?
 
So I got out and went to Target. Took a look at what's actually out there. I think I've got it down to starting with a 9mm.

So far my options at this point are Glock, Beretta 92fs, Sig p226.

Any input on these choices?

Search will deliver 100 different threads about "best 9mm" and opinions are like a$$holes...everybody has one.

From your 3 options, all have their pros & cons. I have the 92FS & P226R. I don't have a Glock. I don't have an appreciation for plastic pistols but that's just me. Glocks are excellent pistols and those who own them will swear by them. It's all about personal preference. I love the Beretta & Sig. You can always buy all 3 and then sell 2 of them later. You may end up keeping all 3. The Sig is at the top of your budget range. CZ's are also top notch and you would have plenty of change left for ammo.
 
Are you absolutely set on a semi-auto? Nothing wrong with them (I have 3) but when I got this
S%26W%20Model%2014-3.JPG

I realized just how "right" a good wheel gun feels. It's a S&W Model 14-3 in .38 Special. (Mind you, I have a S&W 625 in .45 ACP as well:D)

With a wheel gun you won't be tempted to shoot too fast and you won't spend a lot of time chasing brass. And you'll learn good trigger control when shooting double action. Of course, with any centrefire you'll probably want to end up loading your own ammo, so you have to allow for that as well. Depending where you live you may be able to get bulk ammo at a reasonable cost although .22 rimfire is by far the cheapest.

Sometimes good .22 rimfire revolvers come up on the EE, though.

You don't say where you live. If you get to know people at your local range they'll probably let you shoot their guns, which will give you a better idea of what you might like.

One thing is for sure- you'll "probably" end up with more than one.

:) Stuart
 
It all really boils down to what you want to shoot. If you want a 9mil then go hold some different pistols or rent/ask to shoot several so you can get an idea on what you like. Same as for a .40, .45 etc....

My first pistol was a Sig 226 .40 s&w. Loved it, but as other have suggested a .22 is a cheap, fun way to lear how to shoot pistols.

My suggestion is either a CZ Kadet (most reliable, accurate, handling .22) or a nice cheap GSG 1911 with a buttload of ammo to go with it.
 
I would consider myself a beginner however, I've been fortunate to fire the following weapon in different revolver and semi-automatic form factors. ie - 1911, revolver, et al.

.22cal.
.38/357mag.
.9mm
.40cal.
.45mag.
.44mag.

My favorites are .9mm, .40cal. and the .45mag.

The brands I think are the most awesome firearms are H&K (P30L, HK45), Sig Sauer (SP2022, 226, 229), Springfield (XDm), Berretta (92FS), and lastly I think everyone should have at least one or two Glocks in their collection.
 
For a first handgun, IMO, the better option is a quality .22 Double Action Revolver.

Aside from being a good tool for teaching the novice handgunner all the basics and fundamentals of handgunning, the DA trigger, if shot in DA....not SA, will build good trigger habits that will make shooting semi-autos a lot easier, should the novice decide to go into semis.
 
I'd start with a 9mm. 22 is way too light and if you ever shot a pellet gun you can skip on it. 9mm is cheap to shoot so keep that in mind. My first gun was a Glock21 (.45), I loved it but it was way too expensive so four weeks later I bought a G17 (9mm) and never looked back. It is my favorite gun. (I also have a Beretta 90-two which, although mine, belongs to my wife, haha)

Best thing to do is to go out to a range and see if you can try out a gun here and there. Most people love to show off theirs and will most likely offer before you even ask.

Good luck and keep us informed.

Sasha
 
On that note, if I HAD to recommend an actual pistol instead of just "borrow and try as many as you can through friends/ranges/shops", I'd give the nod to the Sig 226 Classic 22. Cheap(ish) pistol, cheap ammo, and then when you're ready to move to a higher caliber you can buy the exchange kit (new barrel, slide, springs, magazine) for a 9mm, .40 or .357 Sig and use it on the same frame. Doing that gives you both calibers, lets you start small if you want, and for less overall cost than just buying a Sig 226 in a centerfire caliber to begin with.

The problem with caliber conversion kits is they cost as much as a whole new .22LR pistol and you usually get stuck with a center fire trigger when shooting the .22LR portion. So for the same expenditure you can have two separate pistols with one in .22LR and one in a center fire caliber.
 
The problem with caliber conversion kits is they cost as much as a whole new .22LR pistol and you usually get stuck with a center fire trigger when shooting the .22LR portion. So for the same expenditure you can have two separate pistols with one in .22LR and one in a center fire caliber.

For Glock and Smith and others you are correct. But not with the Sig: If you buy the p226 Classic 22 first, and then the centerfire conversion kit (might have to be patient for Questar to get the one you want), it's usually a little bit less than a new centerfire p226 just by itself. No idea why, but it is. If you know you want a basic Sig, then that's the way to go.

Some people want their 22 to have exactly the same trigger as their centerfire: Cheap training time with that usually expensive trigger, see?
 
I'd start with a 9mm. 22 is way too light and if you ever shot a pellet gun you can skip on it. 9mm is cheap to shoot so keep that in mind. My first gun was a Glock21 (.45), I loved it but it was way too expensive so four weeks later I bought a G17 (9mm) and never looked back. It is my favorite gun. (I also have a Beretta 90-two which, although mine, belongs to my wife, haha)

Best thing to do is to go out to a range and see if you can try out a gun here and there. Most people love to show off theirs and will most likely offer before you even ask.

Good luck and keep us informed.

Sasha
I agree. Firing a .22 you don't even know it fired. LOL
 
Originally Posted by anonovic.aleksandar View Post
I'd start with a 9mm. 22 is way too light and if you ever shot a pellet gun you can skip on it. 9mm is cheap to shoot so keep that in mind. My first gun was a Glock21 (.45), I loved it but it was way too expensive so four weeks later I bought a G17 (9mm) and never looked back. It is my favorite gun. (I also have a Beretta 90-two which, although mine, belongs to my wife, haha)

Best thing to do is to go out to a range and see if you can try out a gun here and there. Most people love to show off theirs and will most likely offer before you even ask.

Good luck and keep us informed.

Sasha
I agree. Firing a .22 you don't even know it fired. LOL

Agree to both. But we all got to crawl before we can walk, walk before we can run. Caliber of one's first handgun is dependent on available funds, IMO.

Those with lots of disposable income can start with a Desert Eagle .50 or S&W 460. But not very practical or even possible on limited cash. While .22LR handguns do not give much recoil, they will enable one to learn all the basics, economically. When the novice is proficient, he can sell the .22 and go centerfire of his choice/s.
 
Back
Top Bottom