I just recently got in to shooting and have picked up 3 different firearms. Mossberg 500 12 gauge pump for skeet shooting. I've put about 300 rounds through it and it has worked flawlessly. I chose the mossberg 500 over the Maverick 88 because it comes with a set of choke tubes and has a 10 year warranty vs only 1 year on then a Maverick. A ruger 10/22 for target shooting. It also has worked great with 400 rounds through it and not a single failure. Finally I just got an SKS and will be shooting it for the first time this week. Can't wait!!
Sounds like a 22 rifle would suit your needs right now. Good for cheap paper punching and small game hunting. Lots of goodd stuff on the EE to chose from.