Upper and lower are both 7076 aluminum and when oiled should be as close to identical in color as possible. Slight variations in temperature when the part is being anodizied along with the concentration of die in the tank makes it impossible to have uppers and lowers 100% the same unless all done at the same time. The guys we use I think did a great job given the 4 to 5 month timeframe between doing the lower versus the uppers.
The MRA handguards are made of 6061 aluminum IIRC which takes a slightly different anodizing technique than 7075 does insofar as current, temp etc in the process.
That coupled with the fact that MRA uses a diffent anodizer than we do would account for the difference in color.
Only 1 way to prevent this. Anodize the upper and lower in the same batch and get the same anodizer to do all parts. This is NOT practical however.
As Shaun points out CeraKote applied to all parts at the same time will make a 100% color match.
Alberta Tactical Rifle Supply
Canada's Premier Precision Rifle Manufacturer
Please email all inquiries to info@albertatacticalrifle.com NOT through PMs
The Province of Alberta has been suffering for the last 30 plus years with an EAST infection
http://www.albertatacticalrifle.com/
Long Distance is BETTER than being there
How are these uppers and lowers made? Billet? Forged?
Alberta Tactical Rifle Supply
Canada's Premier Precision Rifle Manufacturer
Please email all inquiries to info@albertatacticalrifle.com NOT through PMs
The Province of Alberta has been suffering for the last 30 plus years with an EAST infection
http://www.albertatacticalrifle.com/
Long Distance is BETTER than being there
Not to stir the pot here but I called in to ATRS on Feb 11 to let them know that my IMI mags (Gen 1, basically the 30 round body version of the IMI Beo ones) did not seat easily nor drop free. My metal mags work fine as does my one PMAG. A little filing on the front of the IMI mags makes them run problem free, so I'm not complaining, but there does seem to be an issue with the overhang of the upper receiver. Still happy with mine.