I would use the powders that work best in your rifles. If you need to stock more than one to do it then so be it. Some people use Varget in M14/M1 actions some people say you shouldn't.
It is generally recommended to load between 147-173gr bullets for the M1 Garand or M14 using standard jacketed bullet loads.
A powder in the suitable burn rate range for the action of this type of semi auto gas rifle such as IMR 4895, H4895, AA 2495, BL C2, H335, Win 748, IMR 4064 (and there are others).
A good example would be the Sierra Matchking HPBT .308" 168gr with IMR 4895 or IMR 4064 powder.