Gasoline boy, I have the experience that you assume I don't have.
I acknowledged that the OP was not concerned about long distance shooting. I have used 18" cylinder choked barrel several times, and found it lacking for my purposes. I have shot a lot in heavy cover with 26" and 28" barrels on ruffed and spruce grouse and snowshoe hare. I have found the better balance and smoother swing of standard barrel length is an advantage.
I have been hunting this way for more than 40 seasons. I don't have to "try" much anymore - I know from experience. I have patterned an 18" cylinder choke barrel, and 22" and 24" and 26" etc. etc. Most of those in 12, 16, 20 ga. and in .410 bore. With skeet chokes, and improved cylinder, and tighter chokes. With factory loads and in hand loads, sometimes with spreader wads or other special modifications.