I think to compare the Mauser G98 to a 300$ Yugo milsurp or some other beater is to miss the point. Various companies brought out rifles in 1998 to commemorate the 1898, some like the G98 were all new, others like some marketed by Frankonia Jagd (IIRC) were assembled on old DWM/Mauser recievers, rebarrelled with new wood and fixtures etc. The fact that Mauser decided to honour the design by building new units to me moves these guns out of the milsurp bin, and places them in a category of thier own as new collectables.
To me the Mauser made ones were akin to Mercedes going back and building brand new Gullwing. It may not be a half million dollar original, but it still isn't a chevette either :idea:
As for the shooters, well I wouldn't have blamed anyone for buying one. The idea of a cometically accurate K98, in 308, that is built around new metal, and new wood is actually appealing to me. And given the choice between some old beat up K98 with a frosted bore, a Remington 700, or one of the 308 K98s....I'd choose the later.