A load that I've had a lot of luck with in two .257s is 67-68 grains of IMR 4831 and either the 100 grain Ballistic tip or the 100 grain TSX. The two loads shoot to the same zero in both rifles, which may come in handy some day.
The first rifle was being a little picky until I tried 4831, the second I just started there. My kid is sitting at 9 straight deer with his rifle and this load, including 3 sets of doubles. Nothing needed to be shot twice.