A lot of folks figure the 44 Special is a more accurate cartridge then the 44 Mag, maybe because it kicks less, I'm not sure. I own three of them (Colt SAA, S&W 624, and a Charter Arms Bulldog), and quite like it. Cost of reloading is less then the 44 Mag, and the last time I bought some, factory ammo was cheaper, so I don't know how anyone can figure it's a more expensive proposition. They do recoil less then the magnums, and the revolvers they are chambered in are usually lighter and balance a tad better, important issues for folks that carry and shoot a lot. I guess it's more of an aficionado's revolver then the magnum is. FWIW - dan