.455 Webley MkI, .455 Eley and .455 Colt are different names for the same cartridge - the latter two are commercial designations (British and American, respectively) for the .455 Webley Mark I service revolver cartridge.
The Fiocchi ammunition currently available (and the new-made brass casings) are actually for the .455 Webley Mk II (a shorter case, which was adopted for more efficient combustion of cordite propellant, when that replaced the original black powder load.) So far as I am aware, the only commercially available cases of the longer MkI/Eley/Colt configuration are made from shortened .45 Colt casings (a process which also requires the rims to be thinned - from the front, so it isn't something you can do in the average home workshop.)
Here are the full specifications of the original British service casings:
I use mostly old Dominion .455 Colt cases (i.e. essentially identical to the MkI Webley case) - they are relatively common here in Canada ... watch for them at Gun Shows.
Here is a picture of various .455 revolver cartridges - from left to right: Webley MkII, Dominion .455 Colt (i.e. Webley MkI), one of my reloads in a Dominion case using the bullet from the mould discussed below, and another reload (same bullet) in one of the altered .45 Colt cases, as mentioned above ...
As already stated, Lee makes an inexpensive set of .455 Webley reloading dies (which is what I use) and bullets commercially available for .45 Colt loads - preferably sized as big as possible (likely .454 as NAA has said) and ideally
soft cast (in order to ensure maximum expansion in the bore) will work quite well.
If you are a stickler for correctness and/or turn into a ".455 junky" like me (I now have 6 different revolvers which chamber this cartridge
[Whoops - CORRECTION - that's seven - I forgot one] RCBS makes a limited production mould which casts a virtual copy of the original .455 British service revolver bullet MkII - i.e. distinctive long "pointy" round nose, 265 grains weight, hollow-base - which is the ideal projectile for these loads, though the mould blocks are rather pricey at about US$100 -
While I'm on a roll, so to speak, here are the specs of the MkI and MkII bullets:
And here is the original entry in the British War Department's
List of Changes in War Matériel and of Patterns of Military Stores for the adoption of the Mark I ,455 cartridge: