About the Barnes Bullets free DVD.

snowhunter

CGN frequent flyer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
The free Barnes "X" bullet DVD is very informative with superb graphic's.

However, I do have problem with that of Barnes Bullet in this otherwise fine and free DVD, "proving" that the Barnes "Triple Shock" is more accurate that other hunting bullet, when these different brand, but same bullet weight are loaded with identical powder, bullets, primers, cases and velocity.

It was all to easy for the people at Barnes Bullet, as well as for any other reloader to make a load that is super accurate for one particular bullet, but as all we handloader know to well, just changing to a different brand of bullet, even when keeping the same bullet weight, powder, primer, case and velocity, will produce a different point of impact, and less accurate than the super accurate handload that is this case of the Barnes "Triple Shock" loads is developed for it's promotional, and free DVD that is distributed to anyone who asked for it.

But as they say in the marketing world "little bull go long way" :twisted:

In the same way, I could easily make very accurate and identical 30-06 handloads in for example 165 grain, 30 caliber bullet from Speer or Hornady that would be less accurate for the 165 grain, 30 caliber Barnes "Triple Shock" bullets and so on.

Factors like sectional density, shape, ballistic coefficiency and different lenght of the bullets, etc, will all affect the point of impact differently for identical loads with different bullets.
 
Sierra does the same sort of comparison for their Game King bullets. Look at thier ads.

It's nothing new, and if I ever go runnign around yelling that XYZ bullet is the most accurate without ever trying it, feel free to shoot me. :wink:

That being said teh TSX has been extremely accurate form what little work I have done wiht it and many others have found the same.
 
I thought the video was pretty interesting. It's too bad that they only distribute it on DVD though. I took mine and converted it to an AVI file if anyone is interested I'll post a torrent of it.. it's like 100 megs compressed. I can't see them having an issue distributing it electronically since they're giving it away for free for the asking.
 
Hi,

For accuracy:

I reloaded this fall TSX 150gr for my 30-06 and 300WSM. I tried many hunting and target bullets.

I've never shot smaller groups than the TSX except with Hornady A-max and Nosler ballistic tip.

For construction:

I also did a test on dry phone books wich is really tough on bullets. Even a swift sirocco lost more than 1/3 of its weigth when barnes TSX is very close to 100%.

It's an accurate and a very very tough bullet. Maybe too tough for deer, not sure it will open like shooted in phone books.

Just try it and you will see.

Can't help for sierra, i prefer non-lead tipped bullets.
 
Back
Top Bottom