Whichever targets you choose to print or buy, the important thing is that the paper should be made with very short fibres. Normally papers cost more for their strength, using long fibres to achieve that. But for cleanly cut pellet holes, we need short fibre card stock, very fragile. You can recognise it by folding a corner. If it years a lot on folding, it's probably good for shooting. Papers intended for most uses tend to fold back and forth many times before they'll tear. Even the Gehmann 'practice' targets are too strong, tearing badly with a sub-500fps pellet, so always get the more expensive competition type of buying them.
Something I did for a while was to scrape off the loose bits of my 10 metre, 17cm x 17cm targets, then print 4 small scaled targets in the corners for home use at shorter ranges using an inkjet printer. So I got to shoot a total of 50 shots on every card, 10 at the club and 40 at home.