I have over thirty years of competitive experience shooting red dot sights. Started with a heavily modified Tasco PDP3, then moved to a C-More, then the FTP Alpha series. Currently I have six competition firearms all with Alpha II or Alpha III dots. Two open 9mm pistols (8moa), production optics 9mm (6moa, aim small miss small), steel challenge/PCC 9mm (8moa), steel challenge .22 rifle (8moa) and steel challenge .22 pistol (10moa specifically to really do in Smoke ‘n Hope). And a spare 6moa that will likely end up on my 625 once I find a mount for it.
So the obvious question “ you have SEVEN FTP Alpha dots…why?” The answer is simple. The FTP Alpha’s represent the best compromise between cost and performance for any optic that I have tried. I have tried/owned RTS’s, RTS2’s, Vortex, Doctor, Fast Fires, Romeo’s, Trijicon, Aimpoint, and probably a dozen or so knock-off and off-brand dots. There is a saying when it comes to optics “you get what you pay for” – nice optics are expensive, there really is no getting around that. In the case of the FTP Alpha’s, there is enough noticeable difference over a dot at the $200-300 price point that to spend a bit more for an FTP Alpha is totally justified.
On the other hand, comparing the FTP to a Sig Romeo 3 Max, yea there is a difference, but is the difference worth the price point you would have to pay? In my mind, no. Not like on the bottom end of the scale where spending the extra two to three hundred is almost a no brianer, I really can’t justify the very small margin of performance gained for the cost of a Sig. If you are Max Michel, or Christian Sailer, sure when you are chasing tiniest margins of performance, but for us mortals I honestly don’t see it being worth it.
Back to having six dots on six different competition guns. While the gun is different the sight is, other than the dot sizes I use, essentially the same. That is a great benefit when shooting multiple platforms. My sight window is the same on everything I shoot competitively and I don’t have to spend any mental energy trying to process something different. Couldn’t afford to do that shooting Sigs.
Failures and reliability. Yes, I have had one failure around the battery compartment contacts. There is an easy DYI fix that Fast Toys shared for older models and it works.
Shot 10k through one of my open pistols (all major loads) with the fix and still going strong.
Dislikes. I don’t like anything that tries to be smarter than me, so auto on/off anything like that doesn’t appeal, and I think adds unnecessary complexity. Also, not a huge fan of the new battery tray screw system, wish a more elegant solution could have been found.
Would like to see. A 4 moa! Think this would be sweet especially shooting with the dot occluded. Would also like to see the 6moa just a tad brighter. With the 8 moa I have never had a situation where it wasn’t bright enough, the 6 moa I have wished for it to be just a tad brighter under certain conditions.
Overall, the FTP Alpha’s just work. They hold their zero (and are easy to adjust), they don’t blow up (open guns with big compensators are not friendly to optics), they are nice to look through with a clean crisp dot. For me the choice has been easy and will likely continue to be that way.
David Low