After seeing this thread I did some searching and found quite a few different forums where this topic was discussed, but no real facts. I couldn't find any manufacturers safety data sheets that warned against using aluminum cartridge cases in carbines. I fired off an email to Blazer. I did not specifically ask about firearms being damaged. This was the response I received.
"We have seen case separation on the carbine. The issue is not one of over pressurization of the cartridge but of pressure sustaining longer in the chamber the fact that aluminum is not pliable like brass.
When the round is fired, you have the pressure and heat staying longer in an 18 inch carbine than a 4 - 6 inch barrel. At the same time, the bolt is also starting to come back. The case with its inability to be pliable and its obturation, is wedged in the chamber. The extractors at the same time are pulling back. Sometimes, the case gives way and pulls the head from the body of the case leaving a portion of the case in the chamber. This portion after the pressure and heat are gone is easily removed.
So, it is not an over pressure issue. But more of a sustained pressure and heat expanding the stiff aluminum case and being pulled apart. For carbine style firearms, it is suggested to use the Blazer brass."
Technical Services Rep
Alliant/Blazer/CCI/Speer