Anyone else see the inglis hp on the hsitory channel

joe n

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
298   0   0
Did anyone else see the Canadian soldier with the Inglis hipower cocked and pointed at German prisoners during the end of Norm Christie's show a few days ago? The episode was about determining who killed Michael Wittman in August, 1944. I am trying to find this clip or picture, but not even sure where to start. Hoping someone may have copied it and can post it here. Were my eyes playing tricks on me?
http://www.history.ca/ontv/titledetails.aspx?titleid=116485
 
I watched the program and recognized the pistol as a Hi-Power as well. I'm far from an expert however and could have been mistaken, but it was definitely a Canadian soldier, and definitely an automatic handgun, so if it wasn't a hi-power it must've been a 1911, either of which is out of place in a Canadians hands at that time.

I dont think it's any more plausible that a Canadian soldier in '44 be equipped with an American handgun, than with a British or captured German model, in fact it seems more plausible that he be using captured German of British kit.

I don't know of anywhere online where they upload these episodes, but I have seen the same episode on a couple of times in the past. You might have to keep an eye on the TV-guide and watch the episode again.
 
I saw it, and it was a Hi Pwr.. yes it was cocked and held low pointed at a german POW,, is there something special about that.. I mean why wouldn't it be cocked, these are single action FA's,, also the safety may have been on, but you would not be able to tell as its on the left side.. the view we had was from the right.

I recorded the show.. maybe I can get the image.
 
I missed the clip of the Canadian soldier with the handgun...not too sure if the Inglis HP was issued to the troopies in time for the Normandy invasion...i was always under the impression the Inglis HP finally got into the military supply pipeline in late 1944 .

The HP could have been a battlefield pickup...as the Germans used the Belgium Browning HP also....the Waffen SS were large users of the HP pistol

Clive Laws book on the Inglis HP pistol might shade some more light on this....
 
Thanks Gentlemen, k98action, that would be grerat if you could get the image somehow....it would be nice to be able to determine the date and location of the pic, thanks Genltemen!
Joe:)
 
Seeing as the Canadian P35 pistols were issued so late in the war, there is a good possibility it was a battlefield pick up. The Germans captured and reissued as well as took over production of P35s dureing WWII.
 
If the pic was truly from August 1944 you are right, and Grant R actually suggested this as well. Thanks again Gentlemen:)
Joe
Seeing as the Canadian P35 pistols were issued so late in the war, there is a good possibility it was a battlefield pick up. The Germans captured and reissued as well as took over production of P35s dureing WWII.
 
.... definitely an automatic handgun, so if it wasn't a hi-power it must've been a 1911, either of which is out of place in a Canadians hands at that time.

I dont think it's any more plausible that a Canadian soldier in '44 be equipped with an American handgun, than with a British or captured German model, in fact it seems more plausible that he be using captured German of British kit.

Actually, Canada purchased 5,000 Colt Government Model pistols during WWI and such pistols were, indeed, issued to Canadian servicemen during WWII. In fact, the Canadian Parachute Battalion were armed exclusively with Colt "1911'' pistols until issued with Inglis pistols .... Was the Canadian soldier with the pistol a paratrooper, by any chance?

The Inglis High Power pistol was not even adopted for issue to the Canadian Army Overseas until 3 September 1944 (and even later for the Canadian Army in North America). Before September of 1944, only 22 Inglis pistols (in total) were allocated to the Canadian Army .... for evaluation and testing .....

I am curious why you would suggest that, if the pistol was a High Power, it could have been British? Britain did not adopt the High Power pistol until after Canada did so.

As I indicated in PM communications with joe n, if the pistol was a High Power and the photograph in question does in fact date to August 1944 (rather than being taken later in the war, but used in this program, for example) then there seems little doubt that it must have been an FN-produced pistol, likely captured from a German. After all, following the occupation of Belgium in May 1940, the FN manufacturing facilities were taken over by the Germans and operated for their war effort, and the High Power pistol was an officially issued German handgun .... It was, in fact, the only firearm both manufactured and officially issued by both sides during WWII.
 
Back
Top Bottom