I have the nickel hunter model O/U, I handled a variety of O/U shotguns before I made the decision, and researched the heck out of them prior to getting it. I've handled Brownings, Berrettas, Winchester 101, and the Savage Milano (Made by FAIR) before I laid hands on the Baikal. They are all superior in fit and finish, they are also superior in the # of digits in the pricetag.
I won't say I didn't consider saving up a bit more because they would have been worth it. In the end I found a new production Baikal that was very lightly used. The reason I went with the Russian is it will be a working gun, not some safe queen that is carried in a felt lined case and only sees time at the skeet club. My Baikal is used for birds, and informal clays with friends (and I do quite well with it, practice not the price-tag makes the shooter). Another good thing is since I didn't spend all that much, I won't have a fit if the stock gets a scratch or the bluing wears.
I never took a second glance at any of the Stoeger/Stevens or other Turkish made guns, I'm sure others have had positive experience with them but I never was impressed. I have a friend who had his Stoeger Condor double on him during our informal shoots more than once, it has since been sold, he got a Baikal SxS. I have read about problems other Baikal owners have had and I have yet to experience on issue with mine, I was so impressed with Baikal that I bought a used MP-153 off the EE which IMO is finished better and just as reliable but without the fun of being a double.
The Russians build a shotgun with a no-frills stock, minimal engraving, machining and edges can be rough (or sharp in the case of the trigger guard) but it will go boom when you tell it to.
Cheers