I had very poor results with 168 grain vlds and my 300 rum.
Well no sh*t. Too light a bullet for the case capacity.
I seen two elk shot with them and the first one was a cow shot at about 200 yards . She soaked up 4 hits in the chest and ran for 300 yards before one in the head finished the job.
I refer you to the knowledgeable LR hunters who already said that they were a poor close range choice.
The next one was a good bull shot at about 80 yards.
Was this also using the 300 RUM? Some people really shouldn't be allowed to choose their own hunting rifles.
He was going up a steep incline away from us and took the bullet in the spine dropping him in his tracks.
So, are you the rank-amateur the tried the Texas-Heart-Shot on the elk or was this someone you associate with (making you guilty by association)?
This is very rare for an elk to go straight down as I have found them to be about the second toughest animal to take down.
Yup, elk are right behind Cape Buffalo and just ahead of Elephant.
I then shot my whitetail with the same rig and the first shot that should have went through the shoulder hit and never penetrated more than two inches of meat and never touched bone. This was at about 100 yards a quick follow up behind the shoulder resulted in a hole you could stick your fist in and a very short blood trail.
Why don't people get a bit of knowledge before they start reloading and hunting?
I think they may be a good bullet in say a 308 or something else that doesn't push them too hard.
That's what the 168 is for.
I think that 3500 fps out of my RUM might be too much for them.
And you're surprised that they failed at 80, 100 and 200 yards? A Nosler BT, or Hornady AMax would have failed at that velocity and I wonder how well a Hot Cor, Gameking, Scirocco (a guy I work with thought the 150 Scirocco would be great in his RUM - FAIL) or Interlock would have done? Can anyone explain to me why people buy the biggest, baddest magnum they can get and them use completely inappropriate bullets in them? Spend the money on TSXs if you want to ram them into elk at 80 yards at 3500 FPS (and really you should be able to drive a 180 gr TSX nearly that fast if you've got a decent length barrel). The big 30 and 338 cases (RUM/WBY/Lapua etc) are made to drive big, aerodynamic projectiles (200 grains in the 30 and 300 in the 338) at high velocities for long range hunting. They're not to inflate your ego by having a wicked muzzed velocity with lightly constructed bullets.
The rest will be used as coyote rounds of for gophers. I did shoot 6 or 7 yotes with them and kills were perfect dropped dogs on the spot with out a flicker of their tails after.
Probably the best thing for you and your buddies to concentrate on anyways. Judging by your prediliction for @ss-shooting elk.