It depends entirely on the chambering and throating design of your rifle.... You have not specified... so we are just guessing here.
Generally bullets shoot best at or near the lands... where the rifling starts.... So seating depth is key based on that.
Then you need to check if the seating depth that is correct for the barrel will be short enough to feed in your magazine... if you have one which you have not specified.
So you can find a bullet that shoots well in your rifle if had fed one by one but cannot feed from the mag.
Also, your barrel twist rate dictates the ideal weight of the bullet... you have not specified that either.
As for terminal performance, well that depends on the above... so back to that.
Bottom line is that comparing bullets ambiguously without the whole story is just dumb hunt camp talk that leads to misinterpreted situation specific comments that will get you nowhere.
You need to provide more details.