I am glad to hear that you got that resolved, to your satisfaction.  Is a thing what you should be paying for, when you buy higher end scopes - the quality of the finish on the inside parts, but you can not see them - only whether they work or not.  I think was Nightforce or someone that had an ad touting how many DAYS their springs / internal pieces were tumbled to polish them, versus the HOURS that some competitors used - or maybe it was their HOURS versus the competitor's MINUTES.  
Our son got a 2.5-10 Burris scope - it has a screw turret at lower left - perhaps 7:30 o'clock - by sighting in normally, then snugging that screw, you were supposed to get that reticle housing held more solidly - at 7:30, 12:00 and 3:00 on the turret screw tips.  User has to remember to loosen that 7:30 screw if they want to "re-sight" for different ammo, different range, etc., then re-snug it when done.  Most other old days scopes relied on that bias spring to hold the reticle against the elevation and windage adjustments - so it could flop and bounce around in there, upon firing - the idea, though, was that it was always supposed to end up back at "battery" for the next shot.
I have never owned a "Dusk to Dawn" scope - might be worth your while to set that rifle onto sandbags at 25 yards, centered at a target - then move your eye left /right or up/down - see if the cross hair appears to move on that target - it will move more or less at different ranges - that is parallax sighting error - a scope without AO can only be set to be sighting error free at one distance - the reticle does not appear to move on the target at that one distance.  Most centre fire scopes typically set for 150 yards - the User booklet for the Leupold rimfires without AO, here, say they are set for 60 yards.  Is very easy for user to check for himself - but if you can get your shooting eye in exactly the same position relative to the scope, for each shot, you will be exactly repeating any error, so is not an issue, if you sighted in that rifle.