Can You ID these 2 Old Revolver Cylinders?

[aacollectible]

Both of them are 45 Cal.
Any help is appreciated.

 

[Hi-Standard]

The one on the left appears to be a Webley, and probably in .455 calibre. The one on the right could be a Smith & Wesson and I'd be willing to bet in .455 as well. Probably from a Smith & Wesson handejector and the Webley maybe a Mk. VI?

Edit: are you interested in parting with them? I have both models of revolver.

 

[green]

Agree with HS.

 

[dan belisle]

I think the one on the right is a S&W for 45 ACP, I don't see any clearance cuts for the rims of the 455. - dan

 

[John Sukey]

Neither my .455 S&W or .455 Colt New Service cylinders have clearance cuts for cartridge rims. (and they are still on the guns.)

However my S&W cylinder is numbered in the same place and it does have those two nibs for locatiing the extractor , while the Colt does not.
So the second one is S&W fer sure, and given the other mark, it will be .455

 

[dan belisle]

I'll have to check when I get home John, I'm pretty sure that my NS has rim clearance, and I though the S&W did too. - dan

 

[John Sukey]

waiting with "baited breath"

 

[Gibbs505]

Wow, you guys are good!!

I had the Webley, but not the other!

 

[dan belisle]

LOL, well, work reared it's ugly head and kept me away from the gun cupboard, but tonight, look out! - dan