A forge takes a rectangular piece of metal and turns it into a piece of metal that has the rough shape of a part. By all internet accounts, there are only 2-3 forges producing the receiver forgings for AR-15s. They then sell those forgings to Colt, Bushmaster, Continental, Yankee Hill, Olympic, Lewis Machine, and god knows who else. The quality of the machining that is done to the forging is 99% of the quality of the part. The forging itself is almost irrelevant.
The best way to look at it is to consider Cerro Forge as a material supplier. They sold a lump of aluminum to a machinist who made a receiver out of it. Whether or not you have a good receiver depends on the machinist, NOT on Cerro Forge.