Everyone's favoite question :p which .308 should I buy?

Anders94

New member
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hey guys I'm looking to tap into the collective knowledge and experience of this forum to purchase
a 1 MOA or sub-MOA firearm, price is a non-issue. I've been looking around the internet for the past 9 months at various makes and models (bolt/semi AR10, government profile/hbar) and I'm wondering which one should I go with. This is what I want it to do:

Importance: 1st
Low jam rate above all for me this is one of the most important things as I don’t want to have a critical jam while I’m hunting in the middle of nowhere and have to get it repaired at an armorer
Heavy Barrel and reliability in various hot/cold/wet conditions for hunting
Feed various types of .308 ammunition without jams or large accuracy issues, It’s slightly the same as above but if I have to sacrifice some of the gold-standard sub-MOA that’s fine as long as it shoots well, I hear the Larue OBR has issues with factory ammo but is otherwise the best with premium (I also likely won’t be doing handloads for awhile)

Importance: 2nd
Accept silencers and not have any issues (accuracy or otherwise) in regards to using them outside of Canada where legal
Accuracy Everyone wants sub MOA but long-term I’m thinking reliability will be king for me with 1 MOA or a bit more
Weight I’d prefer to keep it under 10 pounds the only exception would be unless a much more costly military precision sniper rifle eg: PGW Coyote, FN Scar-H TPR, etc. (assuming anyone has tried them) would be significantly better with something in the importance 1st or importance 2nd section eg: reliability, accuracy

Importance 3rd
Semi auto, I’d prefer a semi-auto but in terms of everything I’m asking for above I’m willing to go bolt action if a semi-auto doesn’t fit these capabilities, I’ve heard that semi auto’s are constantly getting better but they may not be all the way there for reliability just yet.

So there’s the question, I’ve looked into a variety of Rifles from the DPMS REPR and the Savage 10/110 FCP HS Precision for the hbar, to the LWRC REPR for the use of silencers without issues (the GAP-10 having some), and the GAP-10 for accuracy with various types of .308, and the Larue OBR for accuracy with premium grade ammo. There’s a wide range of price in all of the rifles, it’s a non-issue though I wonder how all of these will function with silencers. You shouldn’t need to read the rest but there’s more to this post below...



I’ve got to say the Rifle I’m favoring now is certainly the DPMS REPR for that Hbar, 1 MOA accuracy, and being semi-auto but for an all round more reliable rifle the FN SPR A3G with a Hbar, low jam rate, and ½ MOA accuracy looks pretty good to. Or if I can go with my cheap option the Savage 10/110 FCP HS Precision and get about 1 MOA with all of these things that would be nice as my wallet will not be made of both tears and lost dreams. What’s your recommendation? Remember all of my “knowledge” is based on reviews, forums, and recommendations. Just below is one of the best comments I think I’ve heard to "What's the most accurate rifle”


“As I indicated in the previous post, I don't think there is a "best rifle." I think there are "best rifles for my application or specific requirements." That means there might be tradeoffs...for instance, you can basically count on an OBR to be sub-moa. However, most likely because it has a tight chamber to facilitate said accuracy, it is possible that it will choke on surplus or cheap ammo. By the same token, a PWS or REPR or SCAR will give you reasonable accuracy (which to me is two inches or less - mine was sub-moa) and probably be noticeably more reliable with a wide variety of ammo than a rifle that is more of a "match grade" build. Heck, George (GAP) has posted that the GAP10 doesn't like suppressors. That doesn't mean they don't run with them. It means that adding a suppressor introduces issues and variables that have a negative impact on reliability and accuracy. That's common sense, and part of why I got a (LWRC) REPR. Because of it's construction, it ran like a raped ape with a suppressor. That was one of my parameters, and I made an informed decision about which rifle was best suited. My shooting is typically over a fence post or truck hood, which makes a 1/4 moa rifle unnecessary...but most of my targets are live movers in the form of hogs or coyotes - so my focus was on reasonable accuracy with absolute reliability. On a flat range, paper is still right where you left it, so clearing a malfunction periodically is not a big deal. If I'm shotgunning a semi-auto to get it running again, then my hog is gone. Yeah, I'm outing myself there - I don't always get that first round hit.

So, buy based on a realistic evaluation of what you want or need. Not pie in the sky "I want to shoot 1000 yards..but my range only goes to 200" or "I want to shoot 1/4 moa, but I can't afford to buy good glass or match grade ammo" etc.

I'm an equal opportunity shooter - not a fanatic. I recognize the quality and versatility of the LWRC lineup, but I'm not limited to it by blind loyalty. I also own a Spike's Dissy build, a 13.7 inch Noveske build, a .308 PredatOBR 16 inch and am collecting parts for a 3gun rifle build based on a JPEnterprises 18 inch barrel. However, the PredatOBR will soon be sold to a friend, as I'm sure that the 16 inch bolt gun has similar ballistics, suppresses better and eats whatever I feed it”. - chainring on disbanded sniperhide forums
 
Last edited:
Why no HK MR308 for semi auto?

If you want a highly reliable bolt gun there is nothing better than an AI.

You said price was of no concern right?
 
That's a little bit of a surprise price wise, I was thinking 6000 was more of no price limit not 8,499.00. All price aside I always liked FN over Hk in terms of accuracy and reliability though both are good. Specificaly their TPR http://www.fnherstal.com/primary-me.../product/875/878/875/36/_/fn-scarR-h-tpr.html For the previous comment the 10 FCP sounds like it's great for the money, I'm thinking I'd like something that can shoot targets a bit faster but bolt actions don't seem to have many issues like even some of the higher priced semi-autos have so they're a definite, solid contender. Thanks for the recommendations so far.
post addition: I haven't ruled out a separate range rifle either but thanks for picking up on that
 
Last edited:
AR-10 variants are restricted - so there goes the hunting application.

I love my Springfield M1A National Match, but scope mounts are weak points on the M14.

I just handled a Cadex rifle - wow the accuracy, fit and finish is amazing, bolt action though. PGW Coyote is also hard to beat in the bolt category.
 
Another thought...reliability may not be a good trade off against accuracy. Most firearms are pretty reliable these days.

1 MOA could get old pretty fast - are you going to be happy with essentially randomly distributed bullet impacts in an over 6 inch wide circle at 600 yards - I wouldn't for very long.

Read Bryan Litz' excellent books like Accuracy and Precision for Long Range Shooting - 1 MOA is a vastly underperforming system in his Weapon Employment Zone (WEZ) analysis...like not even on the radar.
 
He has good material.


Another thought...reliability may not be a good trade off against accuracy. Most firearms are pretty reliable these days.

1 MOA could get old pretty fast - are you going to be happy with essentially randomly distributed bullet impacts in an over 6 inch wide circle at 600 yards - I wouldn't for very long.
Read Bryan Litz' excellent books like Accuracy and Precision for Long Range Shooting - 1 MOA is a vastly underperforming system in his Weapon Employment Zone (WEZ) analysis...like not even on the radar.
 
I thought I'd get a few opinions. Regardless there was a bit of hunitng I'd like to do but it looks my main thing will be ranged target shooting taking repeated shots. The Tac 2 from Proof Research being a precision rifle but weighing around 2 pounds less then the FN SPR 3AG looks nice. I have to admit that's "down the road" so far I'm leaning towards the DPMS REPR to purchase within 2 months for dedicated range shooting.
 
Last edited:
so....given your preference for the semi auto....i would say a guy could build a M-305 (or a springfield M1A) to do what you want as some others have stated. i have had no problems with my CASM mount and am loving my blackfeather stock. no affiliation, just a very happy customer. this option would require lots of tuning and/or gunsmithing to get you to a reliable 1MOA

other option i would consider would be the ATRS modern hunter in .308, they have a 1 MOA guarantee and many AR components fit on their guns....i believe they start in the $4K range. some people are not a fan and im not trying to start the debate again. just throwing it out there. these rifles are made to order so there are wait times associated with them as well.

far as bolt guns go...the savages are ok, i shot my 10PC for a couple years and it shot very well until it didnt and me and a buddy had spent all day setting up targets to 1000 yards. One of the actions screws had broken off which apparently happens with the model 10's sometimes. between that and the acutrigger it was enough for me to opt to go with a Tikka CTR. but any of the Remington (higher end 700's), Tikka, Sako bolt gun offerings would fit the bill for you. PGW and Cadex make beautiful rifles as well....

ah, so many guns so little time and money :(
 
Back
Top Bottom