Sometimes. I bought a 12 1/2 barrel for my 870 (new not a take off) The indexing of the barrel ring was out so much that if the barrel nut was tight the action wouldn't lock up. Yet it was close enough that it would work on one of my other 870's. In any case I got rid of it and that is my last DA purchase. I know that for some people the light shines out DA's ass but I'm not impressed. I have 4 wingmasters right now and 2 of them have Remington 14" barrels on them, and to compare them side to side leaves the DA seriously lacking. Don't worry I have my flamesuit on