After doing a lot of research and comparing most of the scopes you have on your list(all of them actually) I was down to the NF ATACR F1 4-16 and S&B PMII 3-20 Ultra Short. I'm a big fan of the ATACR F1 5-25, have one on a 338LM and it's been very impressive and stacks up well to the PMII 5-25. I think NF had a great idea with there 4-16 F1 ATACR but the lack of good MIL reticles was the deal breaker for me (I'm not a fan of the MIL-R) I ended up ordering the PMII 3-20 Ultra Short with a H2CMR reticle. If your a MOA guy it would be hard to beat a 4-16 F1 ATACR with a MOAR reticle.(IMO the MOAR reticle is one of the best MOA reticles I've seen)
The ATACR F1 5-25 scopes are not out yet, are you sure?


















































