I'm at a Crossroad! Sig 227 vs HK USP

[tlovell]

Remove

...

 

[JohnnyP636]

I'm looking for change... Currently I have a OD Green Glock 17 Gen 3, a Sig MK25, and a Para GI 1911.
What I'd like to end up with is 2 handguns, one in .45 and the other in 9mm.

The two routes I've been contemplating:

a) sell the 1911 and Glock and purchase a Sig 227. I've heard good reviews on the Sig 227, and the ergonomics and function would be almost identical to the MK25.

b) Sell them all. I've recently developed a hard on for a HK USP and the Walther PPQ. I've shot the PPQ and compared to the Glock I find it more accurate and more ergonomic when I shoot it. Compared to my MK25, it's a close call for me.

it boils down to running the Sig MK25, and 227; or Walther PPQ and HK USP. It's my decision in the end, but I'd like to hear what others have to say that have shot the firearms. Right now I could be swayed either way.

Im kinda in the same boat, I have a Glock 17 and 19 and for my next purchase I want a .45. Im trying to decide between a compact or full size HK or SIG, I think I want a compact tactical HK but I can not find one at a local store to actually put one in my hand before I buy one. All the local stores have the SIG 227 and HK 45 full size, and they are both nice, big and heavy compared to the Glocks but thats just gonna take some getting used to along wiht the .45 punch. Even between the 2 full sizes I cant really say which is 100% better for me, I like something about each better then the other....The SIG was a little more interesting as the sales guy told me it has a aluminum subframe, where as the HK is all polymer frame

 

[tlovell]

True the Sig has an aluminum frame and has a full slide, where the USP is polymer and doesn't have a full slide. I don't know if that would reflect in accuracy or not.

 

[Master-G]

True the Sig has an aluminum frame and has a full slide, where the USP is polymer and doesn't have a full slide. I don't know if that would reflect in accuracy or not.

I'm not sure what you mean when you say the USP doesn't have a full slide—it has a regular slide like other pistols. If I was in your case I'd keep the SIG and the Glock, sell the Para and get a USP .45. The P227 and Mk25 are going to be very similar so why not try something different?