Is This Still (Or Was It Ever) A Viable Concept?

One Lung Wonder

BANNED
BANNED
BANNED
EE Expired
Rating - 100%
5   0   0
Location
Aaaaaadmontin AB
Yanow boys there is simply a time and a place to sit back, relax - and do things the old way. Once in awhile the wife and I will get up early on a weekend and bake our own bread. Or I will get out the straight razor and strop it up for one of the most indulgent of the manly pleasures - the wet shave. And nothing - I mean NOTHING - beats an afternoon with a percussion cap revolver and a whole bucket full of black powder and round lead balls.But sometimes even Yours Truly can't handle the reek of the black powder boys - sometimes I am forced to retreat to the out house for a breath of fresh air!:redface: Some of my finest prognostication occurs in the Fortress Of Solitude.

So it was that I was perched upon the Log Of Ease and contemplating my next adventure as the foolish firearm forum folk's designated Retronaut when I came across one of these in the magazine I was reading:



My gosh. There are few guns ###ier than a 9mm Luger - but this just may be one of them. I have to wonder about the utility of it. I suppose that the closest equivalent to this thing would be one of those HK MP7's. If we were to revive this concept...which gun would you do it with? I was kinda thinking that maybe one of those Berretta 92's might lend itself to a concept like this. Or maybe plasticize the buttstock and hook it up to one of those Glocks with a 32 shot clip? I think we can all agree that this wouldn't go well with a 1911...

For my two cents, it seems to me to be a noble effort to blend the pistol and the rifle. Sometimes blending two different machines works and works well - take the endure style street/trail motorcycles, for example. But to me - it seems that whenever we try to blend the pistol and the rifle - an abortion results. Those Thompson single shot pistols in rifle calibers WILL hurt you if you don't hold them right. 95% of us will have our hands full managing the recoil of a 44 magnum...and yet S&W is selling those massive .460's and .500's like they were hotcakes. I've never seen anyone shoot any of those guns well from a practical field position.

But some monsters - like the one above...are still strangely alluring and tempting regardless of their practicality...:)
 
The Americans played with the ideal of a stocked 1911 [ with a 30rd mag? ] in the first world war , mostly for aircrews to use against each other before everybody started mounting MGs on their planes .

And don't forget the Browning Hi Power with holster stock for the nationalists Chinese.
 
Last edited:
Glocks been doing it for a while.
glockstock2copy.jpg
 
I have never tried to fire a pistol with a butt stock attached, but I would think it would be rather awkward:
28924504.InglisBrowningHighPower.jpg.jpg


I would think this modern version of the concept has much better ergonomics:
RONI_ilus2(40).jpg
RONI%20PLUS%20SBS2(1).jpg
 
Am I correct in my understanding that adding a buttstock to a pistol has no legal ramifications in Canada the way it does in the US? (The whole 'short barrelled rifle" needing an ATF permit thing)
 
Am I correct in my understanding that adding a buttstock to a pistol has no legal ramifications in Canada the way it does in the US? (The whole 'short barrelled rifle" needing an ATF permit thing)

You are correct! It stays Restricted, no matter how much longer the stock or barrel make it. Still a handgun.
 
I've a ad-hoc artillery Luger that has a shoulder stock. It's been too cold for a range report, but one thing I have noticed is the sights are thrown arwy by one's close proximity to them.
Not a huge deal with the toggle action Lugers, but the reciprocating bolt on the Broomhandle gives me pause. Should something fail it might be reminiscent of that silly scene from ' Sin City'
Not good...
 
This picture makes me want to stab myself in both eyes and/or laugh until I vomit.

Hey, at least the rest of the gear looks like it's been put to use. I get a good chuckle at the adds that dress some runway model up in nice new gear hand him a rifle and probably tell him to strike a menacing pose...

As for the Mauser I'd love one...I'll grab a prohib version one of these days.
 
Back
Top Bottom