Keeping Inuit Hunting Traditions Alive

that is very great. as of today for hunting polar bears the out of communauty hunter needs to be on sled dog so that tradition will go forever. hope they will start the same for muskox and caribou soon.
 
That's cool, but I really want to see him hunt with spear and harpoon...like his ancestors did. Is that too much to ask?
 
that is very great. as of today for hunting polar bears the out of communauty hunter needs to be on sled dog so that tradition will go forever. hope they will start the same for muskox and caribou soon.

Hi,

Sorry, are you advising that if an Inuit or anyone else hunting a polar bear must use a dog sled for transportation?
 
That would be traditional.

While it is cool where people are keeping the old traditions alive, success rates are not as high as using modern tools and weapons to improve the success of the hunt, when hungry people must be kept fed.
And at the costs we are experiencing today, and our modern lifestyles,who can afford to hunt with less successful means when trying to keep a growing family fed.

Not saying that anyone here has said that they must hunt only in traditional manner... but I have heard comments to this effect for many years...
Just food for thought:
Put yourself in the same position. If you were forced to hunt with a simple weapon, would you be as successful? Would you resent not being able to harvest any meat for the table because you were forced to hunt by foot with a longbow and wooden arrows or a spear only, when you have a rifle and an atv to assist in getting game out of the back country?
We are all guilty of wanting to improve success rates through use if modern technology.
And at one point, the harpoon was an improvement in technology! As was the the bow and arrow! More effective and efficient than a rock or a stick!
 
While it is cool where people are keeping the old traditions alive, success rates are not as high as using modern tools and weapons to improve the success of the hunt, when hungry people must be kept fed.
And at the costs we are experiencing today, and our modern lifestyles,who can afford to hunt with less successful means when trying to keep a growing family fed.

Not saying that anyone here has said that they must hunt only in traditional manner... but I have heard comments to this effect for many years...
Just food for thought:
Put yourself in the same position. If you were forced to hunt with a simple weapon, would you be as successful? Would you resent not being able to harvest any meat for the table because you were forced to hunt by foot with a longbow and wooden arrows or a spear only, when you have a rifle and an atv to assist in getting game out of the back country?
We are all guilty of wanting to improve success rates through use if modern technology.
And at one point, the harpoon was an improvement in technology! As was the the bow and arrow! More effective and efficient than a rock or a stick!

If they want to use modern weapons like us, then follow modern regulations like us.
 
While it is cool where people are keeping the old traditions alive, success rates are not as high as using modern tools and weapons to improve the success of the hunt, when hungry people must be kept fed.
And at the costs we are experiencing today, and our modern lifestyles,who can afford to hunt with less successful means when trying to keep a growing family fed.

Not saying that anyone here has said that they must hunt only in traditional manner... but I have heard comments to this effect for many years...
Just food for thought:
Put yourself in the same position. If you were forced to hunt with a simple weapon, would you be as successful? Would you resent not being able to harvest any meat for the table because you were forced to hunt by foot with a longbow and wooden arrows or a spear only, when you have a rifle and an atv to assist in getting game out of the back country?
We are all guilty of wanting to improve success rates through use if modern technology.
And at one point, the harpoon was an improvement in technology! As was the the bow and arrow! More effective and efficient than a rock or a stick!

If I really wanted to hunt in the traditional manner, I would accept the limitations, if the goal was to have the highest possible odds of success, I wouldn't try to appear to be hunting in a traditional manner.
 
There is nothing in any treaty signed between First Nations and the government of Canada stipulating that “ traditional” methods must be used for hunting, and all the numbered treaties that guarantee hunting rights were signed during the era of cartridge firearms. The “ traditional method” argument has no bearing on the reality of rights agreed upon by the crown and the signatories of treaties…
 
There is nothing in any treaty signed between First Nations and the government of Canada stipulating that “ traditional” methods must be used for hunting, and all the numbered treaties that guarantee hunting rights were signed during the era of cartridge firearms. The “ traditional method” argument has no bearing on the reality of rights agreed upon by the crown and the signatories of treaties…

If you aren't going to use traditional methods, and equipment, then don't claim to hunt in the traditional manner. Look at his clothing and equipment, even a cell phone, none of that is traditional.
 
Some of this is starting to sound an awful lot like "why do you need that semi-auto to hunt?", or "how is using a trail camera or bait fair to the animal?" For a bunch of people who don't want to be told what to do, we sure are good at telling people what to do.
 
Some of this is starting to sound an awful lot like "why do you need that semi-auto to hunt?", or "how is using a trail camera or bait fair to the animal?" For a bunch of people who don't want to be told what to do, we sure are good at telling people what to do.

I have zero issue with how the person chooses to hunt, just don't claim that he is hunting in the traditional manner, unless he uses traditional equipment.
 
Back
Top Bottom