I doubt you could go wrong with any of them. I purchased a Benelli and I'm happy with it. The only issue with them appears to be getting parts and mods can be tricky to find and expensive, but on an 870 for example parts are cheap and easy to find. Like you I wanted it for hunting geese and ducks and I am not planning on modding the gun. Also the gun fit me pretty well. So the Benelli was an easy choice. Find a store with a knowledgeable and helpful staff try some different one's out and go with the one that suits the purpose and intentions you have. Good luck and let us know how you make out.