Lower pressure factory loads?

Charts are important but never seem to quite deliver the conclusive answers we're looking for. I find the velocities indicated for 2 1/2 Gamebore cartridges surprisingly good and with pressures within the vintage gun limits. How can this be? It either invokes some arcane exception to the usual laws of physics or just does all the usual things that much better. I like that.

FM

Typical nitro "target" loads have a pressure curve that quickly reaches a higher peak pressure and then taper off very quickly thereafter. If you imagine the pressures in the barrel while also imagining the position of the shot charge as it travels down the barrel, with nitro the peak pressure is achieved while the shot charge is still nearer to the breech. After that point, the shot charge is actually decelerating as it continues down the barrel and down range.

The nitro "low pressure" loads use blended powders that are 'retarded' so that the powder burns more slowly (but still burns completely before the shot column reaches the muzzle). The result is the same relative velocity by the end of the barrel, while generating lower peak pressure.

The science that helps this make sense is as follows:

The amount of nitro powder for both kinds of shells is similar. The significant factor is the amount of gas produced by both loads (this will be very close to equal). The powder in the "target load" releases it's energy VERY quickly, producing it's total volume of gas while the volume of barrel space is still very small. The pressure produced is higher because the same amount of gas is produced in a smaller space. After that, the pressure is actually decreasing rapidly as the shot charge is pushed down the barrel.

The "low pressure" loads are charged with enough slower-burning powder to produce the same amount of gas. But, due to the slower burn rate, the full amount of gas isn't released until the shot charge is just about to exit the muzzle.

Since both loads produce the same amount of gas, the net gas expansion behind the shot charge is almost identical by the time the shot leaves the gun which, in turn, produces similar muzzle velocities. The major difference is how fast the gas is produced, and this is what determines the peak pressure.
 
Typical nitro "target" loads have a pressure curve that quickly reaches a higher peak pressure and then taper off very quickly thereafter. If you imagine the pressures in the barrel while also imagining the position of the shot charge as it travels down the barrel, with nitro the peak pressure is achieved while the shot charge is still nearer to the breech. After that point, the shot charge is actually decelerating as it continues down the barrel and down range.

The nitro "low pressure" loads use blended powders that are 'retarded' so that the powder burns more slowly (but still burns completely before the shot column reaches the muzzle). The result is the same relative velocity by the end of the barrel, while generating lower peak pressure.

The science that helps this make sense is as follows:

The amount of nitro powder for both kinds of shells is similar. The significant factor is the amount of gas produced by both loads (this will be very close to equal). The powder in the "target load" releases it's energy VERY quickly, producing it's total volume of gas while the volume of barrel space is still very small. The pressure produced is higher because the same amount of gas is produced in a smaller space. After that, the pressure is actually decreasing rapidly as the shot charge is pushed down the barrel.

The "low pressure" loads are charged with enough slower-burning powder to produce the same amount of gas. But, due to the slower burn rate, the full amount of gas isn't released until the shot charge is just about to exit the muzzle.

Since both loads produce the same amount of gas, the net gas expansion behind the shot charge is almost identical by the time the shot leaves the gun which, in turn, produces similar muzzle velocities. The major difference is how fast the gas is produced, and this is what determines the peak pressure.

Well stated.

In my own (weird?) sense of rationalization (to myself), I've always felt that due to all that has been mentioned above those 2 1/2in Gambore loads perform better in my old sxs with 30in bbls.
 
I bought my last flat of 2 1/2 inch GB Pure Gold 12 gauge in the spring. Called up my dealer, told him what I wanted, 3 days later the shells had arrived and were ready to pick up. If your local dealer has a relationship with Kent it shouldn't be any more complicated than that.

However I wouldn't recommended driving around from store to store looking for them. That might be termed a wild goose chase.
 
Well stated.

In my own (weird?) sense of rationalization (to myself), I've always felt that due to all that has been mentioned above those 2 1/2in Gambore loads perform better in my old sxs with 30in bbls.

In the black powder era, 30" was considered the length of barrel necessary for complete combustion (for a standard charge).
 
Ahsan Ahmed
I should have added; for a given shotsheel lenght / Type / pellet charge. Those loads you are mentioning are not made "For Vintage Shotguns", on wich I was referring.

Also, from CIP the 12 ga, 70mm have the same MAP as the shorter ones (740 bar). 12 ga 73mm (2 7/8") and up (89mm - 3 1/2") have a MAP equivalent to a 10 ga (1050 bar - 15 229 PSI). All CIP 16 ga shell lenght have the same 780 bar MAP standard.
 
Back
Top Bottom