it seems to me that we just finished a thread on making springs, about 2 or 3 weeks ago. I make 5 or 10 springs a year and make flat mainsprings from 3/8 drill rod. Relative to the original poster, if your only source of heat is a propane torch, you might try making a retort to keep the heat inside and the temperature up. The metal has to be red hot minimum to be able to forge it out. after hammering the metal to approximate dimensions, I heat it red hot and anneal it in wood ash. The grind and file to finish dimensions and bend with the metal red hot. Finally for tempering, I heat it red hot and quench in water then draw the metal to spring temper in molten lead (in my casting pot) I use a high temperature thermometer to measure the lead temperature and draw it to 720 - 740 F Since the original poster probably does not have a high temperature thermometer, try floating a thin piece of steel (mild steel is fine) on top of the lead and when the lead is the correct temperature is when the oxidation colours change from dark blue to grey. Hopefully your spring is already submerged in the lead so pull the plug and remove the spring before the lead hardens
for thin springs, many shovel blades are a high carbon steel and should work. Automotive leaf springs, have not worked for me and they might air harden to spring temper although I have never tried that. Final thought; do not use the temperatures shown in blacksmithing books; the colours and temperatures they describe do not work for me.
cheers mooncoon