Milling/Gunsmithing using a Knee mill or lathe rule of thumb

D-man66

BANNED
BANNED
BANNED
EE Expired
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Location
Alberta
Back in the day I kinda put the foot in my mouth when talking to a bunch of guys at the gun store about "O yeah I know how to work a mill, give me ____ an I can get you ____ done for $____. After that I was hounded by an endless parade of guys trying to get me to make them that "one part" that broke on an old gun.

However making stuff on a MANUAL mill or lathe is tedious work, an 90% of it is problem solving. Most hobbiest machinists really are playing a "puzzle game" if you wish to consider it that way.

So to give a rough break down on what's really involved, here are some rule of thumbs to tell anyone who wants you to build some thing for them on your mill or lathe so they know what you have to go through & deal with.

1. If it takes a week to figure out how to do one thing............just to make one of ______, then it only takes another week to make a 1000 of hence _____. Figuring out what you are working on, what the true original dimensions were, what it's made out of, what "setup" or "jigs" you have to make to work on it is the majority of the work. Once you finish the first one, making an endless parade of them afterwards is easy. This happened to me when someone wanted their M1 garand gas tube repaired.

2. Tooling is expensive, no REALLY expensive. Some guys asked me to make some magazines for their 50 BMG rifles. Since those things were impossible to get and super expensive when they did rarely showed up, I took it on. I went to my neighbors old Cincinnati Toolmaster an made 14 1/2 of them out of welded up aluminum square stock. Why 14 and a HALF...............cause the cutting bits I bought wore out (I barely got #14 done), an that was half the cost of the whole setup. So each magazine cost (at the time) around $35 total to make. I only used up 3/4 of that aluminum stock, it's been sitting in the corner of my neighbors shop ever since. I got the aluminum at a scrap yard cheap, the spring stock was also cheap, an I made the followers out of stainless flat bar. Took me a weekend. I got paid $100 each and a case of Dandelion wine for my neighbor ^_^

Yet those were simple End Mill bits..............when they asked me to make something more complex that would require a bevy of tools, I had to say no because it would be cheaper for them to just buy them at the store. Unless they wanted me to make over 100 of that ___ they wanted.

3. Gun stuff always seems to be hardened steel, T7075 aluminum or 416, 7-14 or whatever god awful space age material they come up next. Those require high quality cutting bits, an minimum 3 phase machinery to work on......................an they also send downright lethal metal chips at you at velocities equal to a bullet cutting through you like a hot knife through butter. One guy asked me to fix his glock slide that broke in a minor area that could be tig welded up an milled back down. Even thou it was only 1/4" tiny bead, it sent over a dozen flaming hot "mini bullet" like chips at me that magically found every unprotected spot on my body. The cutting coolant........the coolant does nothing.

So next time you ask a guy to work on such stuff, realize you are kinda asking him to be strapped down an tortured. Modern machine Vertical or Horizontal milling centers have those things in a "booth". Someone at a manual mill is right there beside it one-two feet away.

4. It's not just "cutting it". A lot of parts are "heat treated and/or coated". So sure I can run a mill or lathe to cut a hunk of metal into what you want........O but I don't have a inductive furnace to heat treat it, or coat it with that magical stuff they sprinkle on it. Them funny Europeans would use a goofy form of "lacquer" or a primitive version of Teflon or god knows what. An without it........wouldn't work so now you have to "experiment" to find the right metal to do the job.

Someone wanted a bolt for their FN-49. So I used 416 stainless cause it was the only thing on the shelf I had. Worked great but then it was TOO hard an started to eat away at the receiver which was softer. Finding how to make a bolt out of metal exactly the same "Rockwell hardness" of the receiver was tedious. An then on top of that to make sure the "weight" was close to the original because every other metal varied in weight much differently an the FN-49 was super fussy (not exactly a reliable gun to begin with). Took 4 bolts to get one just right in terms of weight an rockwell hardness to match the receiver. Last bolt job I ever wanted to do.

5. It's a favor or labor of affection. Chances are if they are suffering through it for that dinky lil thing, they like you enough to do it. Otherwise it's all about the money at the usual $1653623636363/hr shop rate.
 
People often assume an hour of machining won't cost much. But when you add in the time to measure a part, the materials and time to make holding fixtures, the time to indicate the part in, the machining time is indeed the small part. Never mind the worn cutting tools, drill bits, taps etc.
 
Y'know what the greatest thing about having a shop full of tools and the knowledge to use them is?

Sending the time wasters that want you to dance and sing for THEM, on down the road, looking for some other sucker's time to waste.

On the other hand, being able to never be stuck for a part, or having to forever ask who can do this or that, that is reliable and does good work....Priceless!

Yeah. One-of's don't pay. Unless you charge enough that they do.

This was the standard #### that we always went through in the shops I was working in. Some #### wanted me to either steal materials from work, or at the very least, spend hours of my time, making stuff that they could buy downtown for next to nothing.

"Yeah, I'll sew you that hockey bag! $250!, You bring me in the materials" "But they are $75 at CTire!" "Yup! That's where I get mine!"

Ask yourself if making a part that you can't get, is worth the effort.

Cheers
Trev
 
Y'know what the greatest thing about having a shop full of tools and the knowledge to use them is?

Sending the time wasters that want you to dance and sing for THEM, on down the road, looking for some other sucker's time to waste.

On the other hand, being able to never be stuck for a part, or having to forever ask who can do this or that, that is reliable and does good work....Priceless!

Yeah. One-of's don't pay. Unless you charge enough that they do.

This was the standard #### that we always went through in the shops I was working in. Some #### wanted me to either steal materials from work, or at the very least, spend hours of my time, making stuff that they could buy downtown for next to nothing.

"Yeah, I'll sew you that hockey bag! $250!, You bring me in the materials" "But they are $75 at CTire!" "Yup! That's where I get mine!"

Ask yourself if making a part that you can't get, is worth the effort.

Cheers
Trev

Quoted for truth!

I'm a machinist by trade and do a lot of one offs at work but it's cut throat and we are in industrial repair and custom builds so it's steep.

I'd say at least half of the time invested it jobs like these is used figuring it out, making/setting up tooling and doing drawings, especially when you can't chance scrapping the part. Factor in tooling(the dollar is killing us) and material plus labour and it ain't cheap to make that "simple part" made from alloy "x".

After explaining that to people they still want to to do them a favour and balk at anything over the price of a case of beer. Hence why I don't bother doing work for random people even though I have almost a full shop in my garage.

I may someday take on part time work but not until I have the time and patience to tell cheapskates to pound sand every day.
 
If you are doing something for your self and it you are not going to sell it --it does not matter how long it takes.

I can do a oil change on my car for App $40 and if it takes me a hour --it only cost me $40
pull plug to Drain-- have lunch-- finish job, including greasing grease fittings -- I would not do it for any one else -- my time is worth more than that
 
I've got a cnc mill and lathe in my garage and the other day someone wanted some lathe work done. He couldn't tell me what needed to be done, how big it was, what material or even draw me a picture. But he still wanted me to "give a rough idea how much this will cost"
 
I've got a cnc mill and lathe in my garage and the other day someone wanted some lathe work done. He couldn't tell me what needed to be done, how big it was, what material or even draw me a picture. But he still wanted me to "give a rough idea how much this will cost"

Was he an inventor, wanting you to sign a non-disclosure agreement? Or wanting you to build his parts for a piece of the millions he was going to make?

At least the mental midgets who start of their conversation, once they hear you have a metal lathe, with "will you make me a silencer" tend to just go away when you tell them you expect cash up front to cover any jail time you might face for doing so.

Inventors are a sure sign that the customer is on a strictly cash up front basis.
 
Not a machinist ,but have a mill and lathe .Set up takes most of the time and the actual cutting is minimal .I seen a neat sign on a fellows shop
I DIDN'T SPEND THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS ON TOOLS TO WORK ON YOUR CRAP FOR FREE
 
I've got a cnc mill and lathe in my garage and the other day someone wanted some lathe work done. He couldn't tell me what needed to be done, how big it was, what material or even draw me a picture. But he still wanted me to "give a rough idea how much this will cost"

funny, get these calls all the time, they have this idea, want a price for thousands but need a couple to play with, my answer is "there is no end to the amount of money of yours I can spend, you just have to sign the checks before I start"

I have the luxury of both a full cnc shop at my business and a shop at home for playing, yes there is satisfaction in making a part either not available or just because I can
 
Yes, its really nice to have the tools to make most the parts i need. But you sure have to know when to draw the line and say its just not worth it. Admittedly i haven't always recognized that line, until i was well into the project, lol.
 
Back
Top Bottom