More Controversy Over Historical Descriptions

Old Guns Canada

Regular
Business Member
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
Location
Delta, BC
Now that we have a lively discussion started over what constitutes single and double action, here is another one to throw at you: black powder reloaders will swear up and down that you MUST load a black powder cartridge to capacity, even compress the powder under the bullet. To quote one enthusiast "you are creating a pipe bomb if you leave an air space in the cartridge...". Here is a request from William "Buffalo Bill" Cody in 1878 to Smith and Wesson, forwarded to UMC: ...Please make us 500 44-100 ctgs. loaded with 5 grains of powder. Put cut paper wad on powder. These are for a special order from W. F. Cody ('Buffalo Bill') who is to use them for stage target shooting." A second order stepped the charge up to 15 grains. " The 500 loaded some time since with 5 grains do not shoot strong enough." The factory load for the 44 Russian cartridge was 23 grains of powder behind a 275 grain bullet. Ira Paine, and "Texas Jack" John B. Omohundro also requested special loads for exhibition shooting.
1ammoscan.jpg

the original .44 S&W, was renamed ".44 American" to differentiate it from the modified cartridge first manufactured at the request of the Imperial Russian government. That one would be called ".44 Russian". Eventually, the Russian version became the standard and would be called .44 S&W Ctg.
 
True, but I don't think a wad of paper would do much to stop the dynamic pressure from building inside the case. It's meant to keep the powder close to the primer so it will all ignite evenly.
 
True, but I don't think a wad of paper would do much to stop the dynamic pressure from building inside the case. It's meant to keep the powder close to the primer so it will all ignite evenly.
it will work just fine it is designed to hold the powder in place many black powder cartridges used that system also early black powder shotshells
you std creating a issue where there is no issue
 
I only reload 1 Black Powder Cartridge 22-15-60 , it calls for 15g of powder .

Different measures I have used are 8g , 10g as well as 15g the space filler used
is white string (any kind) seems to work fine.
...skwerl
Reload string.JPG


Reload punch.JPG

Reload vise.JPG
 
Yeah In larger cartridge cases I use a toilet paper wad to take up the vacant space, if definetely helps with more even powder burn. It does not appear to increase case pressures. Its just funny seeing TP confetti all over the ground during range day.
 
Back
Top Bottom