You didnt mention what model you are considering.
I have a 336 I picked up about 4 years ago and it's a good gun. Not the prettiest but adequate and accurate.
I recently got a XT17 and it seems quite good so far, but only have about 50 rounds thru it, but fit and finish is good.
I also have a Rossi 92 and the Marlin is better finished .
I also got a Henry Big Boy for Christmas and if you get over the absence of a loading gate and have the extra budget I would go with Henry . The Henry just feels and looks quality. As far as shooting I am sure they are similar.