Polymer striker fired or metal frame with external hammer?

Z

zeegler

Regular
Rating - 100%
6   0   0
Location
Niagara
Yeah this question may be done to death, but I'm asking anyway. While weight would be the obviorus factor, it's not like we're allowed to carry these things around here in Canuckistan anyway, so let's ignore that. Considering handgun use is at the range only, let's talk about why you prefer one over the other.

For what it's worth, I own 2 handguns, both of which are metal frame/external hammer.

I've been thinking about getting another and I'm torn between a CZ P10F and a IWI Jericho 941.

:confused::confused:
 
Hi there. This should be an informative topic.
I’ve found it difficult to get used to the mushy feeling trigger pull on striker fired guns. I prefer the feel of a crisp trigger and external hammers.
 
Are you set on those above mentioned brands/models?

You could always look at used Glocks or first gen M&Ps as cheaper alternatives.

I'm a 1911 guy, so you know where I stand on the eternal debate of Metal Vs Polymer or External Hammers Vs Striker Fire..
 
I have both of your latter choices.

The 941 is heavy. Noticeably, demonstrably heavy. I like the trigger, it has a nice short reset and a crisp break. It fits my hands well but I need to shoot with gloves or the stock grips are too slick. It points very well for me and shoots tight groups if I do my part. Uses CZ mags too so plenty of options out there.

The P10F, I think, is amazing. It’s cut high and deep so your grip position is very solid. The trigger is heavier than the 941’s SA mode but it still has a nice break and the reset is shorter than the 941. I don’t like engaging the trigger / safety however. The safety seems to catch ever so slightly (could be my finger position) but after the initial engagement / first round it’s not a factor. There are trigger kits available but I haven’t shot one. It’s very easy to shoot, goes where I point it. The night sights are neat I guess but I don’t shoot in the dark so the three identically sized and coloured dots mean I need to spend a lot more time fixing my grip position to get eight alignment automatically otherwise I’m struggling to find the front sight.

Since the P10 acquisition, I tend to shoot the Jericho less. Of all the handguns I’ve been fortunate to try or own, the P10 is by far my favourite grip position. Rock solid.
 
easy said:
Hi there. This should be an informative topic.
I’ve found it difficult to get used to the mushy feeling trigger pull on striker fired guns. I prefer the feel of a crisp trigger and external hammers.
Click to expand...

Are they all like that? The only point of reference I have is my friend's Glock 17, and I agree that the trigger is an abomination. I'd call it rubbery and numb.
 
ShrtRnd said:
Are you set on those above mentioned brands/models?

You could always look at used Glocks or first gen M&Ps as cheaper alternatives.

I'm a 1911 guy, so you know where I stand on the eternal debate of Metal Vs Polymer or External Hammers Vs Striker Fire..
Click to expand...

Absolutely not set on either of them. I have a CZ75 and I like the Jericho because it's basically just an updated version of it. I assume the feel and weight will be similar.

The P10F would probably be my first choice for a striker fired polymer gun because It's similar to a Glock, but not a Glock. I like to be different. Depending on who you believe, it might be better than a Glock, but a bit cheaper.

I am unable to try guns before buying, so I watch videos, ask questions, and do a fair amount of research before buying.
 
A_guy said:
I have both of your latter choices.

The 941 is heavy. Noticeably, demonstrably heavy. I like the trigger, it has a nice short reset and a crisp break. It fits my hands well but I need to shoot with gloves or the stock grips are too slick. It points very well for me and shoots tight groups if I do my part. Uses CZ mags too so plenty of options out there.

The P10F, I think, is amazing. It’s cut high and deep so your grip position is very solid. The trigger is heavier than the 941’s SA mode but it still has a nice break and the reset is shorter than the 941. I don’t like engaging the trigger / safety however. The safety seems to catch ever so slightly (could be my finger position) but after the initial engagement / first round it’s not a factor. There are trigger kits available but I haven’t shot one. It’s very easy to shoot, goes where I point it. The night sights are neat I guess but I don’t shoot in the dark so the three identically sized and coloured dots mean I need to spend a lot more time fixing my grip position to get eight alignment automatically otherwise I’m struggling to find the front sight.

Since the P10 acquisition, I tend to shoot the Jericho less. Of all the handguns I’ve been fortunate to try or own, the P10 is by far my favourite grip position. Rock solid.
Click to expand...

The weight is not a concern for me. I have a CZ75 and a Girsan Regard (Beretta 92 clone) which are both somewhat heavy.

I really like how long the grip is on the P10F. It does look extremely comfortable. That's partially what attracted me to it.
 
I love my P10F Feels great in the hand , can get up really high on it. Triggers not bad for a striker. Has very lttle muzzle rise compared to either the 941 or my Shadow1. All in all a very nice piece.
What range do you belong to? I could let you try it out if you want.
 
Striker fired are generally more simple mechanically speaking and I guess one could argue they have a quicker lock time? Having said that, I know many older guys (myself included) who just prefer all metal hammer fired guns. Grew up around heavy steel and that's what I like. Gimme a gen 3 S&W over a Glock anytime!!!
 
G_Alan said:
I love my P10F Feels great in the hand , can get up really high on it. Triggers not bad for a striker. Has very lttle muzzle rise compared to either the 941 or my Shadow1. All in all a very nice piece.
What range do you belong to? I could let you try it out if you want.
Click to expand...

I'm on the waiting list for Silverdale. :(
 
shoot an APX before you buy a glock. Slightly spongy trigger but it is striker, other than that, you wont be disappointed.
 
I go back and forth between my Glocks and my CZ 85 Combat. They both run great so nothing to separate them on that score.

Some days I like the weight of the steel gun better, some days I like the consistent trigger pull of the Glock better without the DA/SA transition of the CZ.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom