Recent batch Marlinton

Papaclaude

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
36   0   0
Location
Ottawa
For my 55th BD, the boss allowed me to get a new toy. I seriously considered the Chaparral 50-95 from Marstar, but was unable to locate any brass anywhere in Canada. There was some Sharps stuff available, but it had to be trimmed down, and I'm not set up for it. I was also a little leery of buying one sight unseen given some of the issues others have had with Chappies. So we went down to LeBaron's Saturday and I was interested in several models. A Savage Alaska in 338, a Zastava in 375 or 458, a Baikal in 45-70 S X S, or a H&R Buffler gun. Well, typical LeBaron's had almost nothing in stock. I decided to look at the 1895G. I hate a curved grip on a Winnie-style lever gun, but the G is straight grip. The finish was much nicer than what I'd seen a year or so ago. the metal work is quite good, wood to metal is excellent, the trigger is very crisp and smooth, I'd guess somewhere around 4 lbs let-off. The chekering is not bad, as sacrilegous as it is. The wood finish is quite functional. The action is nice, and will undoubtedly get better over time. Some of the metal edges are a little sharp, but that doesn't bother me. Whoever designed a lever-action with a recoil pad should have their testicles removed with a teaspoon, but then, it will probably be appreciated down the road. I looked at 3 of them, and they were all quite good. Can't wait to go try it in the Spring.

Now, the big decision will be - do I get new (UNCHECKERED) wood and a traditional buttplate, or leave it as is and scope it or put Firesights on it. I'll decide after i try it. But I have to say, I love the feel of it. It's almost like a toy, it's so short, light and handy. Once I try it, I'll post results.

In conclusion, if anyone is considering Marlinton, it might be worth giving them a second look. And the guy at the gun counter says that the last few batches they got were much better than a while back. Mind you, you won't be getting a Winchester, but you'll be paying less than half the price, too.
 
My thoughts exactly when I purchased my Marlington 45-70. She functions well, and while may not have top notch fit and finish, for the price, its hard to go wrong. Especially since it's intended use to for brush hunting.
 
Let me know how no checkering and no recoil pad feel after a day firing 405 gr slugs at almost 2000 fps lol
I know my little sxs is down right angry at 1950 fps
 
I'd still want to see a new Marlin in person before laying money down. Seems like things are getting better, but there's still the odd Remlin out there. I would up buying a Henry after being severely disappointed by a 336 in 35 Rem. It's nice, but maybe I should've just held out for a mint used Marlin.
 
Let me know how no checkering and no recoil pad feel after a day firing 405 gr slugs at almost 2000 fps lol
I know my little sxs is down right angry at 1950 fps

That's part of the question. Either way, I won't be doing anything until I try it out later this spring, but crap, I hate the look of checkering and a recoil pad on those classic lines. A full length mag tube would have been nice, too, but hey, for 640 bucks and change, I'm really happy.
 
From my experiences, while I do like the appearance of the straight stock design, in a modern production 45-70 it wouldn't be my first choice. I have a Marlin 1895GS in 45-70 and with the reloads it is capable of handling, it 'can' be a little hard on the fingers.



Especially with the 'thumper potential' of a modern 45-70, I'd prefer the pistol grip design of the Marlin 444S I have.



In the GS I use primarily three jacketed bullets. The Hornady Interlock 350gr FP, the Speer 400gr. FN and the Remington 405gr FP. Cast, the following variety, with a preference for the 420gr. GC.



Again, with the hot loads and heavier bullets, little hard on the fingers.
 
Seeing the rifle in person is the way to go I agree. I bought a new 1895GS back in the fall at Epps and it took until the fourth rifle before I found mine. It is very very nice and has proven to be a smooth operating and very accurate gun. The matching stainless Skinner is nice too.
 
I just bought some snap caps - they'll have to do for a bit, and the action cycles very smoothly, trigger is cirsp. can't wait to hear it go boom.

Now the question is - scope or fire sights?
 
Back
Top Bottom