Same deer? What do you think?

[Kelly Timoffee]

The one in the black and white just looks like an older animal but the antlers seem very close to identical.

How say you?

 

[kimmer82]

same buck it looks like!

 

[birtch3]

same buck it looks like!

+1 on that

 

[Kelly Timoffee]

The one thing that has me thrown for a loop is the coloring around the eyes.

 

[Whitetail Junkie]

X3 on the same big buck....the curve half way up his left G2 makes him reconizable.

Have fun chaseing him,he is very nice!

 

[track]

Were the photo's taken during a different year? If not, then I say that they are different bucks.............hence, a 4x5 vs. 5x5. If they were taken at different years it is very possible that they are the same buck.

 

[Pathfinder]

If they aint the same..Id say you have two great Looking deer visiting your Feeder / trail cam.

 

[Drillbit]

I don't think they're the same, close though, twins maybe?

 

[bjmurata]

They are close but two different racks.

 

[Sask_Hunter]

You should have been sitting on sept 28. Nice deer!

 

[daveg01]

I would say they are two different but very similar bucks.

 

[horseman2]

Close enough for the girls I take out.

 

[Kelly Timoffee]

Just a few weeks apart.

I have some last year pictures of what could very well be the same guy but younger of course.I'll have to dig into my pictures!

Were the photo's taken during a different year? If not, then I say that they are different bucks.............hence, a 4x5 vs. 5x5. If they were taken at different years it is very possible that they are the same buck.

 

[jables]

They look like different bucks to me, but very close! I'd take a shot at either!

 

[Big Jon]

I think there two different deer. Brothers!

 

[Kelly Timoffee]

Photo 1 I believe shows the 2012 buck in the back ground but younger, and the old boy

Photo 2 is 2011 , ignore the time stamp it is incorrect.Possibly the same as the 2012 deer.

Photo 3 is the old boy again from 2010 , I believe he is no longer with us, natural causes not lead poisoning I suspect.

Silly as it may sound I get more entertainment watching and getting pictures of these animals than from actually hunting them.

 

[CROWCA]

I don't feel he is big enough for you to shoot,send me the gps location and I will try to get him.I am not a trophy hunter like you so I will settle on a small deer !

 

[horseshoe]

Look at the size of that guy! More like a bull than a buck!

 

[broncoo]

Same buck look at the position of the legs. Lighting definetly does not help tell though

 

[CeeZer]

Looks same to me as well.