Blackgunlover said:That is hill billy engineering talking. MP40 would be more consistant in manufacture variances, where each MP38 would be hand fitted which means each part is out of spec from the next. Both were made to the same tolerances. This one looks nice it does not have all the machine marks of an original one.
Blackgunlover said:That is hill billy engineering talking. MP40 would be more consistant in manufacture variances, where each MP38 would be hand fitted which means each part is out of spec from the next. Both were made to the same tolerances. This one looks nice it does not have all the machine marks of an original one.
The MP40 was simplified and used more stamped steel parts rather than milled ones so that it could be produced faster and cheaper than the MP38.Clammy said:So essentially the same gun, only different build quality?
Cheers!
![]()
![]()
![]()
HPL said:The MP40 was simplified and used more stamped steel parts rather than milled ones so that it could be produced faster and cheaper than the MP38.
To say machining is better than stamping is the same as saying a Harley is higher quality than a Honda. Machining shows individual craftmanship. Stamping produces exactly the same thing each, time thousands of times over with the same qaulity as an individual craftsman. Tolerances are the same because they are part of the design, not the manufacturing process. Fit and finish can be made to be perfect with stamping, but the fit and finish will be dictated by what the consumer wants. As an aerospace engineer I avoid machined parts whereever possible. They have too many flaws and variations. CNC can be fine. But any type of machining takes up too much time testing for defects, when pressed metal technology, or casting comes out perfect almost everytime, which makes it cheaper.Deckard said:BLW. I didn't say anything incorrect.
Blackgunlover said:To say machining is better than stamping is the same as saying a Harley is higher quality than a Honda.
Blackgunlover said:Ok someone trying to sell me a harley that is sitting beside any non-northamerican manufacture( including ca am). from even the seventies and later is like trying to sell me a model T ford that is sitting beside a lamborghini that is being sold for half the price, but this is OT. The Harley shows workmanship because it needs a lot just to get to a show room. Sure people like Harley's but it is old technology that is not as good. V-rod is european design.
I don't think even the mighty Marstar could move very many of those at $3000 a pop.Long Range Canuck said:If Wolverine or Marstar jumped on this I bet it wouldnt be long before we had it here, If it wasn't for those companies still in Canada I think we would not have alot of the "Exotics" we now are able to have.
HPL said:I don't think even the mighty Marstar could move very many of those at $3000 a pop.
cancer said:I thought the MP38 was phenomenally rare? Wonder if they managed to get ahold of blueprints or something? I doubt anyone would let them borrow their functioning MP38 to size up the bits and pieces.




























