vehicle mounted deer warning whistles - yea or nay?

I live in the big city where there really aren't any deer.(Scarborough!)
However I have dumb asses stepping out in front of my car J walking on a daily basis, some even with strollers and other children in tow! I'm finding my horn ineffective and my colorful language and hand gestures don’t seem to have any effect either! If I hit these slow moving ignorant sloths I couldn’t even keep the meat!! (stupid corpse handling laws!)
I called the city and a cattle spade like the trains use (although great for moving low riding loud Hondas and most other city obstacles) are not welcome in the city!
Slowing down is not an option because the slower you go the more at risk you are of having someone jump on your windshield trying to clean it with nasty water and then demanding change!! I need my change for beer! ALL OF IT!!
Any ideas how to keep myself safe from hitting these creatures? I had deer whistles but they were shiny and expensive looking thus didn’t last long in the city!:D
Mike
 
i was given a set of them over 20 years ago..i put them in my tool box that got stolen the next day.......and ive yet to hit a deer..
so they have to work;)
its almost like splashing deer piss on you to attract them..:puke:
 
whistles

I've never used them on my vehicle, but I tried them on my buddies tree stand. :) they seem to work well. He never gets a deer.:D

I have also tried whistling in the woods at night. That really works.!!!!! I've yet to hit a deer while walking around whistling.;)

I also have a set mounted on my boat;) Works great!!!!:D May get a set for my canoe soon. I'm still assessing the risk;)

I heard the U. S. military did a comprehensive study with them on aircraft in Iraq. Again a booming success. No deer/aircraft collisions.:D Even at Christmas when there were at least 8 more animal in the area.

So at the end of the day, it is getting dark.:D
 
I was told the sound of the whistle is behind the car as it is travelling.
Not in front to warn or alert anything.
Hence, they were essentially useless.
 
The place I have observed most deer road kills is Wyoming. Therefore, lots of truck owners in Wyoming build special "deer front fenders" made og tubular steel. Most be better than "deer whistles" :)
 
They don't work, and there is some evidence that they in fact enhance the possibility of hitting a deer. Has to do with how sound travels along the roadway in advance of a car. There is a particular circumstance where the reflected sound off of roadside bushlots where there is a fairly solid curtain of trees behind a fenceline back from the highway, causes deer to bolt out onto the highway as they hear the sound coming off the trees. Most of these accidents involve deer grazing in the scrub between the road and the bushlot, and the thinking is that they hear the reflected sound of the car/whistle coming off the trees, and therefore run toward the highway to escape.

I spent a fair bit time some years ago travelling the Blue Ridge parkway in Appalachia by tour bike, and there were a fair number of bike/deer collisions (not pretty) - most of the bikes who hit deer were using whistles. It was uncommon to see a bike without whistles in a deer collision.
 
I haven't tried them myself,but I have noticed that almost no one mounts them according to the directions on the package.The package specifies a minimum distance between them,yet almost everybody mounts them much closer together than specified.With a motorcycle,it would not even be possible to mount them as far apart as the directions specify.In order to work,they would also have to be kept clean,which means keeping them clear of ice and snow in the winter and bugs in the summer.I guess that these are the reasons that I never bothered to try them in the first place myself.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom