The allen keyed set screws, set into a v-notch on the circumference of the turret beneath the cap: When I set mine, the rubber seal created a fairly strong pressure chamber which finally gave to my increased force, so that the notch and set screw would be in alignment. Obviously this cannot be seen with the cap in place, but it is possible that you are experiencing the same air pressure buildup and resistance to correct re-installation of the dial and the set screws are not set in the v-notch. Just a simple thing that is easy to miss, which might be the cause. Of course both my scopes are sitting on 0 moa bases... so I may not be visualizing the problem correctly.