If it's walnut.....do the following: 1. Package it up.
2. Send it to me at Rare Wood Creations
3. get out your cheque book.
J/K (sort of)
Chemically strip/clean the stock with stripper, follow the directions.
Wipe down the entire stock with LOTS of mineral spirits to remove any stripper.
Allow to dry overnight, then steam out any dnts with a soldering iron applied to a wet facecloth.
Sand to 220, then wet the entire stock down with distilled water, then let dry. The wood will go "fuzzy", so sand again...180, then 220
Repeat the distilled water (Do NOT use tap water), only this time sand 180-220-320.
Pick up some 400 grit wet-or-dry paper from the automotive section, slather the stock liberally with minwax tung-oil varnish, and sand the living crap out of it with the 400 grit paper, adding more finish as it starts to absorb. When you think you've sanded enough with the 400, do it again.
The stock should be a big slimy mess at this point (this is good), let it sit for 20 minutes then wipe off the excess with a clean rag. Dont over-do it...you dont want to strip the slurrry out of the pores.
Allow to dry overnight, then aggresively rub it down with a piece of burlap to burnish the surface...should almost be shiny.
Allow it to dry another two days, then get a can gloss of wipe-on poly (doesnt matter if you want it matte...get gloss) and apply a coat. wait 4 hours then apply another coat (don't sand), allow to dry overnight. Lightly scuff the surface with another piece of 400 grit wetted down with water, wipe dry, and repeat the "coat...wait two hours...coat...allow to dry" process once more. You now will have four coats of wipre on polly. Sand the entire surface with more wet 400 grit, being carefull not to go through the poly. Just rub until the finish has no more shiiny spots. If you want a matte finish, give it a rub with some 0000 steel wool at this point, and give it a coat of paste wax.
If you want more gloss, follow the 400 grit with 800, then 1500, then 2000 grit papers (use lots of water), give it a coat of turtle wax POLISHING compund (yes, for cars) and buff the crap out of it., re-aply TW, buff it again (Burlap works good for this)
Finally, apply a coat of paste wax, and buff with a cotton cloth.
I still like option A better though!
Ryan