I've owned one new in the box in 12 gauge, I've also owned a Remington 870 upland special and a Browning BPS upland special. After having the luxury of trying out all 3 the Winchester would have been my third choice. Fit and finish were fine, The speed pump can take some getting used to as mentioned above and I also short stroked it a couple of times which is a little frustrating when bird flushes are scarce. I just found the stock with the safety at the front of the trigger was more difficult to get at when your hand was on the straight stock. I personally found the gun just didn't fit me as well as the other two and the only one I currently have is the Remington, which comes up as quick for me as any of my other SxS shotguns I've used for birds. The fit, finish and quality of the gun I had was fine, with nice checkering for grip etc., but even though I got it at a clear out price, I sold it just for the personal fit and I guess because of what I was already used to. So my suggestion, is if possible handle it first, many dont like the straight grip on a shotgun and the safety position etc. is personal and whatever your already used to. Just my 2 cents.