Winchester Wildcat Target/Varmint revisited: range report

rimfiremac

Regular
Rating - 99.1%
108   1   0
Location
SOntario
I recently picked up a heavy barreled Wildcat off the EE here to check out and tune up for a buddy who's getting into the sport. I was looking forward to seeing the rifle and was especially interested to try the fit and feel of the gun to see how it compares to my trusty Savage Mark II BV.

Taking it out of the box, I was pleased with the weight of it, but thought that the stock could be slightly larger, which would in turn improve the balance marginally. Not that the balance was offending, but it is a little nose-heavy at first feel. I had some experience with the standard version of the Wildcat, and was not very impressed with the action, and this one was similar, somewhat rough with noticeable friction present due to an undersize bolt body. That feature would need work. The trigger, surprisingly, was a very pleasant two stage, and felt to be about three pounds or so, but with an unexpectedly crisp break. It has a similar feel to the Savage trigger when breaking... a sound and feel that bring to mind one word 'thunk!'. Not like an Anschutz 'tick'... this thing means business.

Out of curiosity and impatience, I dove into the rifle before taking it out to the range and testing its 'out of the box' capability. I had plans for this thing, regardless, so off I went. First thing I did was dive into the trigger mechanism and back off the stop nut as far as I reasonably could. With this complete, the trigger pull tested between 9.2 and 9.6 Newtons, or, 2 pounds give or take an ounce or two. Again, the break is crisp, and the two stage design is a welcomed feature. I stoned the sear minimally, but didn't get too carried away, as I have heard some manufacturers use sintered parts with an exterior hardening treatment, which can be ground off via stoning. Taking the roughness off the sear seemed to make a slight improvement to the overall feel of the break, but it could be my imagination.

Next up was bedding the action. I bedded the areas around the action screws with a fast setting steel-epoxy resin, and had it bedded in one evening. The bedding took out about half the rotational slop that was present pre-bedding, and by my unholy opinion, was satisfactory. The barrel, of course, was very well free-floated care of TOZ.

While the bedding was setting, I took a few minutes to disassemble, clean and polish the bolt. After re-installing, it felt a little better, but I have a feeling it might be mostly to the cleaning and removing grit, then lubing. Movement was fairly smooth, but it was easily felt that if the bolt was dry, binding would occur easily.

Reflecting on the work so far, my next task with the rifle was to leave the bedding to set for another 24 hours (while 60+ hours would be preferred for a centerfire, I reckoned that between the quick-set resin and low recoil factor the lost time would not make much of a difference), then take it to the range and give it a whirl.

Arriving at the range with a couple boxes of cheapie ammo, and two Lapua flavors for contrast, the first thought that crossed my mind was that I severely misjudged the windchill! After sighting it in against the snow (handy!), I put it through some basic paces off the bench at 100 yards. Upon chambering the first round, I was reminded that the barrel has a 'semi-match' chamber- its a tight fit! The bolt was a little firm in the action, and the ejection works best with a little red enthusiasm associated, both of which are detractors, but both livable, and if I was shooting off a bipod instead of a makeshift rest, operation would be much more pleasant. I burned a couple rounds off offhand, and the bolt's firmness is much less noticeable in that position.

Performance, as always, will 'make or break' the opinion, but the Wildcat met every expectation and then some. I was expecting 1.5 MOA accuracy with mid-quality fodder, and it showed that and better in some cases. This time the performance eventually became a point of frustration, effectively bursting my bubble about how my BV can keep pace with an Anschutz Match 64. With the right ammo, the Wildcat showed very, very consistent performance, and could easily give the BV a run for its money on paper. As follows, groups are best 4 over best 5, except in the case of Scoremaster, where its best 6 and all ten.

Jan13004b.jpg


RWS Target Rifle: 1.41"/ 1.67" - not too bad for the particular flavor.
Federal 714: 2.275" and 2.258" on two separate targets- it grouped when sighting in, but choked when it counted.
PMC Scoremaster: 0.445"/ 1.785"- this cluster was surprising, and the flavor shows great promise. Sorting may help.
Eley Pistol Match: 1.390" - better than some, but not stellar compared to expectation.
Lapua Super Club : 0.920"/ 0.960"- this is where its at- consistent and accurate- keeps pace with reasonable expectations! This wasn't a one off, either, as seen below with Standard Club, it will go sub-inch with Lapua.

Jan13003b.jpg


For an idea of how it would do in an informal match, the following was shot with greasy old Lapua Standard Club- 98-1x isn't too shabby.

Jan13005b.jpg


All in all, I was very impressed with the value of the rifle. Coupled with its shorter barrel and lighter weight, it could reasonably give the BV a run for its money in performance. If it keeps up its current performance with the Lapua ammo, I might have to find 'another' rifle for my bud...

Still searching for the holy grail...
 
I ended up selling one of these actually because I purchased it spur of the moment, while I was at a gun shop, and I never even fired it. I have thought about buying another one because I know that they are quite a real bargain for a heavy barreled gun, and adjustable trigger. They are'nt a CZ, but they do seem to be in the same class of a Savage.

Do you say that the quality of the rifle is on par with the Savage ? I have been on the fence on to buy another one of these, or to spend the extra coin and get a CZ.
 
The quality is not quite par with a Savage, but the performance is, and it does have its own perks such as a slightly shorter barrel and lighter weight, which makes it easier to trek with in the field, if ever is desired. The BV is a solid rifle, but the price tag for that is its heft.

The bolt on the Savage is marginally better- it is more solid looking in build, but from a functionality standpoint, the TOZ bolt achieves the same end result but with much simpler and lighter construction. When the sear trips, both bolts drop with a resounding thunk... the Savage a little harder than the Wildcat, but again, the end result is the same. The Savage might have a slightly faster lock time, but if that's what you're worried about, neither are even on your radar screen.

I think that with the right lot of decent ammo, as shown, the Wildcat will perform on par with the Savage and the CZ- I'd venture that on the average, with carefully selected ammo, performance for all three brands will be identical. The CZ might shoot the cheap stuff well also, but I've seen the BV print impressive groups with Fed 714 and Blazer just the same. I'd expect similar from the Wildcat. All flavors are subject to the occasional Friday afternoon turnout, as with any product. At closer ranges, dropped shots are less obvious and aiming error is smaller, so I would suspect that some of the shown groups would half at 50 yards and print in one ragged hole at 25.

The extra bucks on a CZ will be reflected in a smoothed action, absolutely, but the triggers on the CZ's are also in need of work or replacement: +100$ for a rifle basix trigger. The Wildcat trigger is straightforward to tune, but you've gotta hold your mouth right to grab the stop nut, and the Savage trigger is dead nuts easy to lighten. Both, however, have bolts that are not buttery smooth by a country mile.

I can live with a rough bolt in a $300 practical knockaround rimfire that's minute capable at 100 yards. If I want the refined feel of quality workmanship, I reach for the Annie- but it's not my go-to for potting rabbits with it in the bush. Just my 0.02
 
Last edited:
Mac: I agree, excellent "review"... I'm considering picking up a "cheap" rimfire for some <100m shooting out at the range, and reports like this are extremely helpful in making a decision. Thanks for taking the time to do so.
 
Yep @ 200 meter's breaking clay pigeon's are sure fun.
I love the fact that this thing is an MOA 22LR rifle :p
 
Back
Top Bottom