SA or DA Revolver?

I really like double action revolvers and own more of them than any other type of firearm. But they aren't for everyone. I see a lot of people sell them and when I ask I've been told point-blank more than once "it's too hard to shoot". The double-action trigger is a rewarding challenge for myself but if you just want to go out and enjoy some casual blasting, which is a fine pursuit in itself, then I think for a lot of people the single-action revolver is a superior choice. As others have said, many end up using their DA as a SA anyway.

If you want a new gun that comes with learning a new skill buy a double-action. Join a pistol shooting league and be the hipster shooting a revolver in IDPA/IPSC/whatever. It's great fun.

If you want to go out and shoot occasionally, like shooting farther distances, and want a gun that really stands out aesthetically from your current collection, a SA revolver is a great option. I have no problem admitting that the appearance of the SA is a large part of what attracts me to it. They're very pleasing. Shooting them is a great deal of fun as well, especially if you like shooting for precision as the design encourages patient and paced shooting. I also find the reloading process novel instead of being a burden or feeling too 'time consuming'. Nothing about these guns was designed to be done at breakneck speed (though you certainly can learn to shoot them fast).

I don't think you could go wrong with a Blackhawk if you're just going to have an individual shooter, since the adjustable sights will let you play around with load development more. I like the appearance of the fixed-sight guns, but admittedly they do restrict your reloading a good bit more as you just hunt for a suitable POA/POI mix and then you're done.

I also second the recommendation of picking up a Schofield reproduction. They are the coolest guns ever made that aren't S&W Model 15s.

As far as calibers, the 45 LC is the caliber that just feels right to me in these guns, but the 38/357 is considerably cheaper and super versatile. Another thing to consider with the 357 is that down the road there are more firearms chambered in it (rifles and handguns) so there's a better chance for cross-platform usage. There's lots of 45 LC guns out there are well the but vast majority of current production revolvers are 357 magnums.
 
I also second the recommendation of picking up a Schofield reproduction. They are the coolest guns ever made that aren't S&W Model 15s.

Schofield's are "cool" in looks and function. A single break ejects all the cartridges. This one is in 38spl….
DSCN1393_zps040b608f.jpg

DSCN1401_zpsb0ca420c.jpg

DSCN1398_zpsec7bccee.jpg
 
How do you find the sights on the Schofield's? I've been checking out Taylors & Co as they carry 3 models. Having problems getting on to Uberti's website at the moment.
 
How do you find the sights on the Schofield's? I've been checking out Taylors & Co as they carry 3 models. Having problems getting on to Uberti's website at the moment.

If you're only familiar with modern HG sights the half moon front sight on the this Schofield takes some getting used to. Both front and rear are fixed but were spot on, very robust and made well.....just like the rest of the revolver.
DSCN1400_zps69a50c5f.jpg

DSCN1402_zps46965ff1.jpg

DSCN1399_zps921c2216.jpg
 
I would go with a Ruger GP-100. Mine runs as smooth or smoother than my 686 and is built a little stouter for those who like to unwind a bit with stout loads. I cast the 200 gr Lyman bullet for light and heavy loads. The 200 gr bullet is very accurate and from talking to friends in the US a great hunting bullet. It has a tendency to tip over when it hits flesh making for a wide wound channel.

I also have a Ruger 45Colt/45acp convertible and find both rounds to fire with the same level of accuracy using cast bullets sized .452. My convertible is the flattop so the heaviest Ruger Only loads are a no go BUT I can tell you 8.5 gr of Unique under a 260 cast bullet provides enough recoil for me and would do a number on most that breaths and certainly adequate for jaguar sized animal. This same statement can be said for a .357 DA/SA revolver. The 4.2" Ruger/686 Smith are very handy guns in stainless and ones you should really consider. Having a big gun that weighs a ton -think Redhawk - hanging off your hip or in a chest rig that is going to be slow to get into action is likely not going to do you much good if things get ugly up close and personal. Too, carrying a heavy handgun around all day gets old quick.

Take Care

Bob
 
At least if you buy a DA you can shoot SA if you decide to. I find myself shooting DA revolvers SA more often than not. I DO however like the look of single action a bit more than the DA counterparts! Good luck :)

The trigger might feel the same if you do it that way but the feel of the gun in the hand and the way it recoils is different. And for lots of us that difference is a big part of the decision.

And then there's the look of it when it's not actually in hand. That counts for something as well. But for me it's more about the differences in how they feel and shoot.
 
The trigger might feel the same if you do it that way but the feel of the gun in the hand and the way it recoils is different. And for lots of us that difference is a big part of the decision....But for me it's more about the differences in how they feel and shoot.

That's a good point. I find I shoot a single-action with one hand...always have, not sure why. And I tend to shoot a DA/SA (regardless if it is pre-cocked or not), with two hands. I don't assume others do the same but it goes to your comment about the "feel". My SAs also tend to have longer barrels than my DA/SAs or DA-only, maybe that has something to do with it.

I don't shoot like Clint though :)
 
I'm shattered. I'll bet you don't believe in the Easter Bunny or Santa Claus either? :p

Of course there is a Santa Claus don't be stupid eh. He comes every year at Christmas everyone knows that.. As for the Easter Bunny ......weeeeelllll he comes in the spring and leaves chocolate eggs all over my gun room so there.

Take Care

Bob
 
Back
Top Bottom