Being a long day at work I've had a lot of time on my hands. I've been been some reading , internet browsing and thinking. I was wondering how traditional style mukluks and moccasin boots would fair out in the field, they are supposed to be quiet , their design muffles the sound of stepping on a branch that cracks. The few reviews I've read seem to be positive and people seem to love their mukluks or hide moccasin boots. One particular set of mukluks I was looking at are steger quetico tall mukluks. As crazy as it sounds I might just give them a try. They are rated for cold temperatures and seem comfortable. Same goes for moccasin knee high boots which I haven't been able to find a pair yet. Am I completely out to lunch or does anyone else think these would make great outdoor hunting boots?
not to split hairs but mocs let you feel that branch before you put your weight on it, they aren't a muffler.
If you practice walking ball/heel instead of heel first you can get a lot quieter in short order.
The #1 for game friendly in the bush isn't always quiet, as you can never be 100% silent. Slow, and broken are more important than silent. Only man marches through the bush. Walk slow and stop often...pull some grass...
I wore mocs for decades, bow hunting, dog sledding, in camp...I always carried a set in my pack or saddle bags.
They have their place but are not good in every situation as leather has limitations as does certain designs. Stone bruises, stubbed toes and such are more likely than with boots. Designs with a raised rib around the foot hold snow on top and will get wet through the seams if they aren't oiled up properly. Leather is slippery as snot on a door knob in snow and when wet, or when oiled up to be water resistant. I never liked them much for snow shoeing because after many miles the ball of my foot would get tender where the break over board was. Not a big issue if you only do a few miles though.
I still have several pair of mocs and a set of sheepskins with a gum sole that are super light weight and kept my feet warm in the tree stand when Sorrels wouldn't do it.
To your question, no they don't make "great" outdoor hunting boot imo. They have their place and do a fine job for many things, but your feet have to be used to them to take advantage.
If you want to be a moccasin man, go barefoot as much as possible so your feet get used to it. Because that's what mocs are really, barefoot with a thicker skin.
I think a good compromise for bush walking is a set of those cheap thin soled canvas sneakers and a pair of those elastic ankle supports. The kind that are like a stiff sock with no heel or toe. Not so much for the support but for the protection. You get some feel and protection without weight.