Wow, this one's a real head scratcher. The military has had BMI limits and policies on fitness and fatties for years, but some always get thru because of the inevitable inconsistencies in how the policies get applied. Personal discipline/restraint/pride in appearance are expected of military people. I spent a lot of time in messhalls and chowlines over 32 years, and still do when I'm doing training work for the Army, but I never thought to blame the cooks or the chow for how much of what I chose to put on my plate.
Some of us rotten old meanies actually used to put people on counselling and probation for being overweight. Its too bad that not everyone did. I think it was mostly an Army thing because some light blue ones were quite shocked when they found themselves kicking up dust on the carpet because of it, especially in the lax NDHQ environment. It always seemed to get back to just how motivated the individual was about maintaining their weight and military appearance.
I remember one pretty smart guy who we kept in a holding pattern for promotion to major until he lost "X" amount of pounds. Damned if he didn't bear down on it and shed the pork and was then promoted; and didn't he then go ahead and pack it all back on! He was a very able fellow who just couldn't control his eating;they used to joke about him not being able to use his computer because of the food spills on his keyboard. When it came time to pick someone for one of the commemorative medals I had him in the office to tell him that I thought he actually deserved it, but that I was too embarrassed to stand him in front of the General to receive it, so no medal.There was also a female officer in NDHQ who was so obese that she was ordered not to wear a uniform because of the unmilitary image that she presented. I had the job of reviewing officer PERs for consistency one year and found that she was highly rated in all categories, incl appearance. I kicked the PER back to her organization and told them that it would not be supported as it was, if only in fairness to the other people who did have the pride and personal discipline to keep themselves fit.
This fellow has a 26 year service pension in return for his service, yet he went angling for more with a pretty lame case. Good thing I wasn't sitting on that pension review board.