My first 1911 - Remington R1 Carry Commander CT

Zedbra

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
45   0   0
Location
Squamish
I have been a wheel gun for years - shooting mostly Dan Wesson .357s. All year I have been thinking about 1911s, reading a little about them here and there, liking the history, and then the 'need' started to grow.

I did ask a fellow shooter that has owned several brands of 1911 from budget brands to expensive customs what he recommended for $2k CDN (with my preference being a Dan Wesson)? To my surprise, he suggested an R1 - saying he believed DWs were priced higher than their value.

With Prophet River's year-end sales happening, I succumbed to that craving and jumped right into the deep end and ordered my first 1911 without ever firing one; a Remington R1 Carry Commander Crimson Trace with (2) 7 round mags and (3) additional Remington 8 round mags. I should add that this is also my first semi-auto centre fire pistol, so I have much to learn (and appreciate).

I was nervous about causing an 'idiot scratch', but found tear-down and cleaning quite easy. Happy with the cleaning and oiling, I took it to the range today. Here are my initial impressions:

* I like 45 ACP. Snaps similar to my .357 hot loads but I can see those big holes easier.

* It took me a few mags to adjust to this pistol having a 6 o'clock sighting, whereas all my other revolvers and rim fire pistols have target sight (frame) holds.

* I shot 100 rounds without a hiccup of any kind, no FTF, FTL, or FTE

* The trigger has more take-up travel than I like. Is there a way to clean that up?

* All but 1 mag drops cleanly. I'm thinking it may just need to be used a little....or is there a little tune I can do to it to get it to drop?

* I quite like the Crimson Trace grips. I have quite large hands and usually have difficulty finding grips large enough without going custom. These grips were comfortable for me and the laser helped me adjust to the 6 o'clock sighting. I will need to adjust it a bit, as the laser was low at 25 metres.

Other than the trigger long travel take-up, I am smiling big time; very content with the style and brand. I can see these 1911s multiplying in short order - I still want a Dan Wesson and I think a Colt for nostalgic reasons.

Here are some pics from the range yesterday, it was a cool -10c but at least it was sunny. These targets are set at 10 metres and I was an additional 1 metre back from the firing line to stop my shells from flying into the snow (I will reload after some more reading). All shot while standing and shooting free hand.

The first target pic here shows the POI from aiming based on target (frame) sights that I'm used to, only then realizing the gun is a 6 o'clock hold. The squares on the target are 1" each.
 

Attachments

  • Remington R1 Carry Commander CT.jpg
    Remington R1 Carry Commander CT.jpg
    47.2 KB · Views: 340
  • Realizing it has 6 oclock sighting.jpg
    Realizing it has 6 oclock sighting.jpg
    21.8 KB · Views: 340
  • First 100 rounds groupings 2.jpg
    First 100 rounds groupings 2.jpg
    33.4 KB · Views: 339
  • First 100 rounds groupings 3.jpg
    First 100 rounds groupings 3.jpg
    29.8 KB · Views: 335
Last edited:
That's darn good shooting at 35 feet! Well done! You've obviously learnt the right shooting fundamentals.
I never thought that .357 recoil was similar to .45 myself. .45 is a nice warm push and .357 is a loud snap. I think .357 is more like .40S&W.
 
That's darn good shooting at 35 feet! Well done! You've obviously learnt the right shooting fundamentals.
I never thought that .357 recoil was similar to .45 myself. .45 is a nice warm push and .357 is a loud snap. I think .357 is more like .40S&W.

Thanks. I reload my .357 with 5.6g of Titegroup, pushing 158g FMJ bullets - the muzzle flip and snap even with my 8" full underlug shroud is similar to this .45 based on first impressions.
 
Thanks. I reload my .357 with 5.6g of Titegroup, pushing 158g FMJ bullets - the muzzle flip and snap even with my 8" full underlug shroud is similar to this .45 based on first impressions.

It's all individual perception, I guess.
Did you shoot the groups on the bench or standing free hand?
For your first time, those are pretty tight groups. And I can see them getting tighter once you get used to your 1911 and your first semi auto.
 
It's all individual perception, I guess.
Did you shoot the groups on the bench or standing free hand?
For your first time, those are pretty tight groups. And I can see them getting tighter once you get used to your 1911 and your first semi auto.

I always stand and free hand with all my hand gun shooting. I tried shooting from a bench and bag only once as I put a scope on one of my revolvers and was aiming out to 100 yards - I didn't like it and don't understand the appeal. Come to think of it, I stand and free hand a lot of my rifle shooting as well. I just edited that post to include that info, as people always ask - thanks.

 
I always stand and free hand with all my hand gun shooting. I tried shooting from a bench and bag only once as I put a scope on one of my revolvers and was aiming out to 100 yards - I didn't like it and don't understand the appeal. Come to think of it, I stand and free hand a lot of my rifle shooting as well. I just edited that post to include that info, as people always ask - thanks.


Free handing a 8" Dan Wesson will definitely train you to keep your arms steady!
Weirdly, I find I'm less accurate when I bench shoot handguns also.
I assume you'll be reloading for the 1911 also?
Experiment with 185 and 200gr bullets if you do. Get a bit more zip with those!
 
Free handing a 8" Dan Wesson will definitely train you to keep your arms steady!
Weirdly, I find I'm less accurate when I bench shoot handguns also.
I assume you'll be reloading for the 1911 also?
Experiment with 185 and 200gr bullets if you do. Get a bit more zip with those!

You should feel the weight of the loaded DW with the 10" full underlug barrel - it's a wrist work-out. Do you have any powder suggestions for the .45? Also, any suggestions on how to possibly take up some of the trigger pre-travel?
 
You should feel the weight of the loaded DW with the 10" full underlug barrel - it's a wrist work-out. Do you have any powder suggestions for the .45? Also, any suggestions on how to possibly take up some of the trigger pre-travel?

Does your trigger have the pre-travel adjustment hex key? Is there a screw through the trigger?
Otherwise, I would suggest checking out a gunsmith in your area. Dlask would be a good one to ask.
When I used to reload, it was for a P220. I used lead semiwadcutters in 200gr over 4.5gr of W231. I've gone as high as 5 gr testing out 185gr JHPs but mostly the lead SWC for normal plinking.

You can go as high as 6grs but I've never tried that.
 
Does your trigger have the pre-travel adjustment hex key? Is there a screw through the trigger?

Yes - it does and I managed to tighten it up with just a little take-up left in there; most videos suggested that is the way to run these 1911s. I'll try it and adjust as needed - thanks.

Measured the trigger weight and it came in at 4.2# - I can live with that for target use.
 
I always stand and free hand with all my hand gun shooting. I tried shooting from a bench and bag only once as I put a scope on one of my revolvers and was aiming out to 100 yards - I didn't like it and don't understand the appeal. Come to think of it, I stand and free hand a lot of my rifle shooting as well. I just edited that post to include that info, as people always ask - thanks.


Oh man....that's quite the set up.....congrats on the 1911...I'm sure there will be more....
 
I took a friend of mine to the range - temperature was -2c and no one was there all day except us. Put another 200 rounds through the R1 without any issues whatsoever; I'm starting to get used to the sights and can appreciate the laser to check my shots. I'm already thinking of my next 1911. ;)
 
I decided to do a complete tear-down today and see how this thing works. God bless Youtube. I polished the barrel, cleaned up all the internals, polished the trigger bar, polished the sides of the sear, and polished the disconnector so now my trigger pull is a crisp 3.25 lbs! I'm impressed how easy it is to work on these and I'm sure with a little more research, it would be easy to get this down to a 3# trigger.

I also noticed that my front sight is a Trijicon sight and not a Novak tritium as they advertise. Not sure why that is, but I like it when sighting.

Upon further inspection - this front tritium sight doesn't have any glow whatsoever. So I guess that is the first warranty item in the first two weeks.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom