Depends on your rifle, but usually Crosman airguns and other American similar airguns prefer Crosman pellets. They're great in those rifles, but don't fare well in the European guns, generally.
I have an odd rifle that seems to shoot just about anything relatively well. CPHPs will group under 1" at 50 yards for me, but JSB Exact Jumbo Heavy never misses a 1/2" target at 50 yards when I'm benchrested, and I really mean never. It's boringly consistent. For me, it's worth the extra, especially for hunting. I buy "bulk" from Dan at the forum store. I get a slight discount on 10 tins. SSSO offers a discount in bulk, as well.
That's a great price on those CPHPs, though! Can I ask where you get that deal?