Ruger Comp Vs Hunter vs Target

D

-Doug-

CGN Regular
Rating - 100%
7   0   0
Hey,
Currently I have a M&P22 but cannot get real accurate shots based on it's crude sights. Thinking of picking up a more accurate intended.22. Does anyone own or can recommend the pros and cons of the ruger comp, target and hunter.

Which would be best for precision .22Plinkster splitting card type shooting and why?
Thanks

Doug
 
I have both a 22/45 Bull barrel target model and a 22/45 Lite, the heavier Bull barrel is a bit more accurate than the Lite version, although both are more accurate than my M&P or GSG. The only con I have ever heard of for the Ruger's is the take down, some people have difficulties, but truthfully if you have half a brain and minimal skills they are not difficult to take apart or reassemble. I shoot them way more then either of my other .22's plus, you don't need to strip them after every range trip, I usually clean after 500 or so rounds.
 
smokeater40 said:
I have both a 22/45 Bull barrel target model and a 22/45 Lite, the heavier Bull barrel is a bit more accurate than the Lite version, although both are more accurate than my M&P or GSG. The only con I have ever heard of for the Ruger's is the take down, some people have difficulties, but truthfully if you have half a brain and minimal skills they are not difficult to take apart or reassemble. I shoot them way more then either of my other .22's plus, you don't need to strip them after every range trip, I usually clean after 500 or so rounds.
Click to expand...

The new mark iv series takes 5 seconds to take apart and put back together now.
 
All those models will be nice accurate shooters. Depends on which flavour you like and how much you are willing to spend as the new 6 7/8" Comp and Hunter models are not cheap. The new generation 4 models are less finicky to take down than previous models, but if you want to save some cash I would have no issues going for an earlier generation.

Personally, I'd get either a previous gen Ruger Mk or if I was willing to go close to $1K for a new Ruger MKIV comp or hunter, I'd probably go straight for a nice used Smith 41.
 
I will be getting the MKIV Hunter model and have it threaded soon. I have a MKIII 22/45 and don't care for the grip.

My wife just purchased the S&W Victory and likes it alot.

Side note, our S&W M&Pc 22's are horrible for target shooting. They work great for playing around and hitting larger targets but were not designed for shooting rats at 40yds
 
If you mean true target guns, MP are not it, Tradex has some real target guns listed ,used ones, extra mags are the problem with them.
 
gdawg said:
All those models will be nice accurate shooters. Depends on which flavour you like and how much you are willing to spend as the new 6 7/8" Comp and Hunter models are not cheap. The new generation 4 models are less finicky to take down than previous models, but if you want to save some cash I would have no issues going for an earlier generation.

Personally, I'd get either a previous gen Ruger Mk or if I was willing to go close to $1K for a new Ruger MKIV comp or hunter, I'd probably go straight for a nice used Smith 41.
Click to expand...

I second this. A 5.5 heavy barrel MKII will be a fine shooter for you at around $350.00-$400.00
They work well with high velocity ammo, and even better with standard velocity.
Trigger kits can be had as well to lighten up the pull. Mine had a Volquartsen trigger kit.

If you want a great target pistol you can cry once and buy a used Smith & Wesson Model 41 for around $950.00
They are excellent pistols. Mine has a 1.5 pound trigger pull. It loves cci standard velocity ammo.

I wanted one 20 years ago. I did not buy it because they were expensive-$500 dollars.
I bought and sold 16 other 22lr pistols over the years. I had some fun but lost some money buying & selling.
If anyone asks, I tell them to get a used Model 4I. If they absolutely cannot afford it, I tell them to get a Mark II to enjoy
until they are ready to move up to a 41. My .02
 
I own a mkiii comp and a browning buckmark target, both are different flavours of the same gun. The only difference is the buckmark cost $250 less and didn't need a trigger kit( additional $120 or so). Love my ruger, but comparable gun for less money is out there if you do a little searching.
 
I've owned a few MKIII's and did not notice any consistent accuracy advantage in any of them. However, I did find a good fitting grip and balance made a difference to me.
22/45's....too thin, bull barrel.....too nose heavy, 4.25" standard(taper barrel.....feels just right in my hands with iconic looks. IIRC it cost ~$400 BNIB.....
 
Rugers are not target guns. They are great plinkers and fun guns but if you want a truly accurate .22 check out some of the true target guns that Tradex has listed. Walther GSP's, Pardini SP's, FAS602's. They have some bargains. They even have some cheap Model 41 Smiths in need of new grips.
 
caperaway said:
Rugers are not target guns. They are great plinkers and fun guns but if you want a truly accurate .22 check out some of the true target guns that Tradex has listed. Walther GSP's, Pardini SP's, FAS602's. They have some bargains. They even have some cheap Model 41 Smiths in need of new grips.
Click to expand...

With respect, the Ruger Mk series are extremely accurate pistols. I have a 5.5" bull barrel Mk. 1 that can put 10/10 on an 8.5 X 11" sheet of paper at 50m, and 8/10 of those will be in the black.
 
stevebc said:
With respect, the Ruger Mk series are extremely accurate pistols. I have a 5.5" bull barrel Mk. 1 that can put 10/10 on an 8.5 X 11" sheet of paper at 50m, and 8/10 of those will be in the black.
Click to expand...

And when they can all be kept in the 10 ring like a GSP or a Pardini the Ruger will be considered a competitive target pistol.
 
caperaway said:
And when they can all be kept in the 10 ring like a GSP or a Pardini the Ruger will be considered a competitive target pistol.
Click to expand...

And when Pardini sells a pistol than doesn't cost the price of 3 or 4 Ruger MKs, people would care. It is accurate enough for target shooting and will out shoot most folk, though not our resident olympians.

Tradex used ones are very reasonable in price, but may very well be shot out beyond your 10 in the 10 ring standard.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom